
đ How to Use the Archive Search
Use the search bar below to explore the National Citizens Archive. This is a powerful tool designed to help you quickly locate specific information across reports, transcripts, videos, and exhibits.
â
Tips for Best Results:
-
Search by keywords or phrases
Enter a single word (e.g., vaccine, mandates, Charter) or a phrase (e.g., informed consent, adverse events). -
Use specific terms
The more precise your search, the more relevant your results will be. Try names, topics, or key terms from testimony. -
Try different variations
If you don’t find what you’re looking for, try synonyms or alternate wording. -
Results include multiple content types
Your search may return matches from reports, witness transcripts, video pages, and other archive materials. -
Results are ranked by relevance
The most relevant matches will appear first.
âł Please Be Patient
This archive contains a very large volume of content, including thousands of pages of testimony and documentation.
-
Initial results may take a few moments to load
-
If results appear incomplete, allow additional time for the search to fully populate
-
You can refine your search at any time to narrow results
đĄ Helpful Tip
Once you open a document (such as a transcript or report), you can use your browser’s Find function (Ctrl+F or Cmd+F) to quickly locate specific words within that page.
Search this site
837 results found with an empty search
- NCI-R-03-Item-6-0 | National Citizens Ar
6 Recommendations 6. Recommendations The intention of this section of the report is to provide a convenient and easy reference or listing of all of the recommendations made in Section 5. Each of the separate subsections contained in Section 5 are reproduced here, but only the recommendations themselves are included. For a detailed discussion of the rationale for the recommendations and the basis in testimony, we refer the reader to Section 5. Report Content Reader Page đ Note to Readers The content presented on this page has been adapted for online viewing and navigation. Due to formatting limitations within the web display system, certain elementsâsuch as layout, spacing, and visual structureâmay differ slightly from the original report. For the complete and fully formatted version, we encourage you to download the official PDF available on the Report Information page. The PDF reflects the report exactly as it was originally written and published.
- NCI-R-02-Item-7-2-7 | National Citizens Ar
7.2.7 COVID Impact on the Social Fabric 7.2.7 COVID Impact on the Social Fabric When describing COVIDâs impact on Canada, the question really comes down to this: Where to begin? Certainly, the tiny cracks in the social fabric may have surfaced pre-COVID, but in the aftermath, these splinters have become deep crevices. Regardless of where one turned, the threat of even further damage was frightening. At the beginning of COVID, the prevailing narrative was âtwo weeks to flatten the curve.â Most of the citizenry at the time understood that a pandemic could pose a very real threat. Thus, for the most part, the majority of Canadians were willing to concede to a temporary shutdown for the sake of society as a whole. But what happened when two weeks became two months? And two months, two years? Some argue COVID is multifaceted and complex. Decisions were made with the goal of protecting public health and safety. Any criticism, even constructive commentary, was quickly dismissed, and dissenters outside the one-sided, prevailing narrative were silenced. Nevertheless, pointed questions needed to be asked. Perhaps the most pressing question: Were the governments and the public service honest with the Canadian people? Traditionally, when a nation comes under siege from outside forces, its citizens unite to defend the countryâs interest. However, the response to COVID and the federal governmentâs invoking of the Emergencies Act appeared to garner the opposite response. Instead of rallying together in one accord, with a determination to save Canadian ideals, citizens willingly complied with ever-changing health mandates, even when these bordered on the nonsensical. Indeed, mask-wearing, social distancing, and experimental gene therapy tended to be accepted as the price for participating in society. In actuality, it could be said that Canadaâs COVID policies brought out the worst in people. The sense of defeat was palpable in the hearts of men and women on the streets. Hope and optimism for the future was not generally observed within the populace. For many Canadians, there were simply too many hurdles to overcome, so they compromised both principles and conscience just to survive. Subsequent research points to the negative developments that have permeated nearly every aspect of Canadian society. While, admittedly, a multitude of factors influenced the advance of the pandemic, it would be remiss to think, after hearing the witness testimony, that ulterior motives were not at play. The witnesses alluded to a variety of societal breakdowns, and the irreparable damage that followed in the aftermath of COVID dictates. It is important to recognize the burdens placed on people from all walks of life, journeying within multiple layers of society, because the long-term effects of COVID mandates are intergenerational. In fact, as stated, it could be generations before the harms committed over the years 2020â2023 can be undone, or perhaps they can never be undone. Noticeably, lawlessness increased, but not from the citizenry. Rather, the wrongs that were being committed stemmed from all levels of government officialsâthe few that believed they knew much better than the populace. For example, the rule of law, wherein the same application of the law applies to the homeless on the street as the judges dressed in robes in the Supreme Court, has been violated. The supremacy of God was sidestepped. Constitutional rights and freedoms were discarded as if these protections never existed. In many situations, ordinary people who stood for this country, have fallen. Normal day-to-day lives have been damaged. Education and learning opportunities for young people were disrupted. Medically, suicides, addictions, and domestic abuse increased at phenomenal rates. Adverse medical effects from COVID injections were not accepted by health agencies, even though medically qualified, professional physicians attested to the vaccine injuries to patients. Scientists who contested the prevailing narrative became outcasts. Family businesses were destroyed because these were not considered essential. Neighbours forgot how to trust one another. In its wake, a host of economic, social, health, legal, and public policy tragedies have yet to be acknowledged by the authorities responsible. One outcome is definite. We are not the same society we were before COVID. Many questions remain. These should include whether the populace is satisfied with the emergence of a new political model that, in essence, replaced all the tenets of parliamentary democracy and justice in Canada. Certainly, the idea that legislators (in consultation with the electorate) no longer decided our destiny during COVIDâwhere Canadians shop, whom citizens befriend, the beliefs and opinions people subscribe toâshould have been concerning enough. But appointed (non-elected) health authorities and public service employees, who with the stroke of a pen can further impose predetermined restrictions on oneâs conscience and arbitrarily decide where oneâs inherent rights to live as free men and women should start and stop, should raise serious alarms. Is this the society Canadians want? How Did We Get Here? The reality is the elected officials vacated their posts and instead, abdicated or gave over their respective political and public administration responsibilities to chief medical officers employed as bureaucrats within public health. Equally notable, these individuals were also allotted extraordinary powers that clearly went beyond the scope of good governance and accepted democratic principles. Therefore, in this specific context, did the actions of chief medical officers and corresponding health bureaucrats border on the political doctrine and practices recognized in political science circles as absolutism. After all, this didnât just happen in one province, or even within Canada. The one-mind that emerged occurred in most jurisdictions around the world. The Western ideals that Canadians had come to cherish were extinguished by the stroke of a pen. But whose pen? Who decided that the rights and freedoms of citizens no longer mattered in Western democracies? And why, in such a blessed democratic nation as Canada, did so many blindly follow? As the numerous witnesses alluded to while sharing their personal testimonies, ordinary citizens were arrested and detained in prisons for standing firmly on the rights and freedoms established in the Constitution Act, 1867 ; the Charter; and the Bill of Rights. Where was the presumption of innocence? What happened that negated the administration of justice? The questions do not end here. For the three COVID years, the ever-changing mandates differed, depending in which part of Canada one lived. Language changed. The legacy media suddenly became experts in public health, without ever attaining a medical degree. The content these journalists did not substantively understand translated into a word-for-word repeat of press releases disseminated by public health officials. The more bizarre the content contained in health alerts, the easier it became for media to reportâfor example, 8 p.m. curfews, wherein no citizens were allowed on the streets in QuĂ©bec, or how travellers were required to obtain travel papers prior to entry into New Brunswick or Nova Scotia. The Atlantic bubble zone was yet another exampleâwherein residents in the Atlantic region could travel freely throughout the eastern provinces without question, but Canadians living elsewhere were subject to additional scrutiny and COVID preauthorizations. This same legacy media also gained an expertise in public shaming. Anyone who opposed the prevailing narrative and, most particularly, those with medical and scientific expertise were labelled as âconspiracy theorists,â delivering a message of âdisinformationâ and âmisinformation.â For their servitude, the legacy media was paid handsomely by their political masters in Ottawa. Truth, investigative journalism, and professional ethics were no longer priorities of mainstream news agencies. As quickly as the government could print news releases, the media adopted them as their own. There could not be a timelier era for the biblical prophesy forecasting when âright is wrong and wrong is rightâ to come to fruition. For example, the term freedom fighter , according to artificial intelligence, is subjectiveâmeaning what one group views as freedom, another might consider an act of terrorism or insurgency. Therefore, artificial intelligence does not acknowledge freedom as an inherent, God-given right in Canada. Any responsible educational inference that willingly omits absolute truth (truth that cannot be manipulated) when constitutional tenets are already defined should scare Canadians. Further, it appears the media, alongside federal and provincial government institutions, only resorted to historical context for villainy so they could then mangle it beyond recognition to prove a desired outcome consistent with COVID mandates. Are there even recommendations capable of countering this increasing trend toward propaganda-type reporting? But legacy media were not the only perpetrators. Social media quickly joined ranks, becoming judge and jury of all commentary that allegedly contravened community standards. Facebook, YouTube, and other social media giants censored content, disciplining or suspending privileges of any user who posted content concerning COVID. At no point did governing authorities, the judiciary, or Crown prosecutors challenge these actions by social media conglomerates, even though freedom of thought, belief, opinion, and expression clearly includes freedom of the press and other media of communication in the Charter. There is also another emerging concern regarding dialogue and actions that are contrary to the Charter. Increasingly, it appears Canadiansâ rights and freedoms are only concrete and tangible âwhen reasonable.â For clarity, there is no âwhen reasonableâ attached to Charter rights and freedoms. These rights are inherent and God-given. These are not within a governmentâs purview to take away. The framers of this nation recognized and founded Canada on these pillarsâthe supremacy of God and rule of law. These same citizen protections were then reaffirmed and entrenched in 1982. Further, these citizen rights are guaranteed to be free from any interference or intrusion from government agents of the state. All government institutions are expected to remain neutral, which by extension, prohibits government from selectively cherry-picking which legal activities are deemed reasonable and which are not. These same limitations on government apply to Charter-protected accommodation. It is herein that the intersection of citizens and governing authorities requires further investigation: the COVID messaging, the forceful actions of authorities, and the question of whether Canadians are once again willing to sacrifice their individual and collective rights and freedoms whenever governments or bureaucrats impose mandates in the future. Before garnering a response, it may be insightful to review some of the COVID measures imposed over the last three years, and how COVID mandates and government dictates negatively affected the social fabric. Children were told if they visited their grandparents, grandma would die. If these same young people visited their friends, their peers could become infected. Families had to make an appointment to visit loved ones, and far too often, this included bringing the negative results of a rapid COVID test. Children could not play in parks or playgrounds. Social time was not allowed. Libraries, museums, and youth activity centres were closed. So, too, were hiking and skiing trails. Education was moved to remote or online. Student-learning expectations and curriculum outcomes were minimized. Structured schedules, so essential to those who plan their lives around them, were disrupted. This, in particular, had a significant impact on people with special needs, as the program services necessary for their health and wellbeing were shut down. The gaps in access to education were even more pronounced when marginalized communities are factored in (for example, financial stress, increased worry, increased conflicts). Public policies contradicted each other. For example, soup kitchens in Ontario were permitted to feed up to 50 persons in a facility at the same time, but religious services held in the very same building were limited to five or ten in-person gatherings, depending on the COVID mandate in place at the time. There was the witness who shared her story. While her mother was alive, she was not permitted in the hospital. But when her mom died, she could sit by her motherâs bedside and hold her hand. Spiritual care for a palliative patient was conducted through a window. The five children of a man who was assaulted by a disgruntled customer could not see their father before he died. There was also the heartbreaking story of one young teen who ventured down a path from where he could not return. Health authorities were adamant that COVID vaccines were effective and safe, and yet after administering the vaccine to seniors living in long-term-care facilities, there were more COVID outbreaks, more COVID deaths, and presumably more adverse injury events. In Ontario and QuĂ©bec, specifically, there were reports of the elderly being found in deplorable conditions. When employees walked out at one facility, the resulting circumstances were so shocking that the Canadian Armed Forces were called in to help. Individuals with special needs, including learning disabilities, or mental health issues were put on hold. Countless Canadians waiting for surgeries continued their medical struggle without healthcare intervention. The elderly became even more isolated from friends and families. Many died. The short- and long-term impacts on vulnerable populations are still to be tallied. The homeless, who generally find shelter on city streets and in wooded areas, were forced to find alternative ways to comply with 8 p.m. curfews because COVID measures and lockdowns already prevented them from finding a temporary warming space, bathrooms, or showers in government buildings and not-for-profit facilities. Charitable organizations, including churches, were prevented from offering in-person support programs within the community. For example, Alcoholics Anonymous moved all meetings online. Temporarily, this might have been considered an acceptable compromise. However, if the persons needing AA relied on free computer usage from the library, they no longer could receive support because the libraries were closed. Ironically, the very addiction these recovering addicts were running from was still open and ready to serve. Funeral restrictions were maximized, adding to the grief of family members and friends attempting to say goodbye to a loved one. Proper burials and funeral services looked very different from pre-COVID. As a consequence of the pandemic, the grief and mourning processes were disrupted, negatively affecting peopleâs emotional wellbeing. One witness reported that the COVID practice was contrary to the bereavement recommendations for grieving families listed on the Canada.ca website. For the first time in known history, middle-aged women, typically with children still at home, were dying by suicide. The mean age of these women was 47 years old. This demographic was never identified as a risk group. Witnesses spoke of other deaths by suicide as wellâof beloved ones who could no longer see the light of this day that would guide them safely into the next. Mobility restrictions were linked directly to the COVID mandates in each province and territory. In larger provinces like Ontario, different rules applied depending on the health district one resided in. Internationally, borders were closed by governments. Hotels were secured as quarantine facilities for travellers arriving in Canada. The whereabouts and activities of Canadian citizens were tracked by public health agencies. Those who travelled outside of Canada were subjected to specific protocols. Inside Canada, where travel from province to province is a guaranteed mobility right in the Charter, several provincial governments imposed additional obstacles and border checkpoints. Citizens were often quarantined. Within the quarantine procedures, travellers were questioned every day by health officials. In several provinces, documentation required by health officials included a mandatory travel itinerary complete with details of overnight locations (including the names and addresses of all residents in the home) if spending time at a family memberâs or friendâs home. Two examples show the length to which governing authorities would go to control the populace. In September 2021, Prince Edward Island, for example: ordered anyone travelling to the province be tested, regardless of their vaccination status; recommended travellers 12 and older be tested again between the fourth and eighth day after they entered the province; required that school-aged children under 12 who returned to PEI from travelling, test negative for COVID-19 before attending school; ordered unvaccinated or partially vaccinated travellers to isolate for eight days upon entry and then test once again. The provinceâs PEI pass, which permitted entry onto the Island, would only be issued to people who showed they were at least two weeks removed from their second COVID-19 vaccine dose. In northern Ontario, travellers were required to sign in at eating establishments with verifiable personal contact information. Washrooms in most restaurants, tourist information centres, gas stations, and rest stops were closed to the public. The changing rules became so complicated that Restaurants Canada created a chart informing food and drink establishments of public health requirements, which coordinated with colour codes. For example, green was to âprevent,â yellow was to âprotect,â orange was to ârestrict,â red was to âcontrol,â and grey was to âlock down.â Accommodations added further layers of restrictions. Hotel swimming pools and gyms were closed. Newborns were taken from their mothers at birth under the pretence that the infant or mother may have COVID. Depending on the specific hospital, the mother could not see the child for up to 24 hours. Families were denied access to loved ones in hospitals and long-term-care facilities. Scheduled surgeries were put on hold. Many patients on long waiting lists died in the interim. Access to information requests were ignored by the majority of federal and provincial governments and agencies. Bank officials who forced patrons to line up outside in the winter months based their orders on social-distancing and customer-limit protocols. During the day, when staff were at the bank, an added emphasis was placed on sterilizing ATM machines; but in the evening, there were no employees ensuring compliance with COVID measures. Unions are supposed to protect the rights and interests of paying members. The purpose of unions is to negotiate with employers on collective bargaining issues and workplace concerns. During COVID, however, witness testimony repeatedly pointed to the failure of unions to represent their members. Unions did not ensure vaccine-related policies were fair or transparent, and that workersâ rights and/or personal medical concerns were taken into account before employment status decisions were made. There was rarely accommodation made for employees with medical and religious exemptions. The unions did not negotiate for alternative work arrangements. Safety measures such as ventilation and sanitation, and additional safety precautions designed to protect both vaccinated and unvaccinated employees were not raised with the employer. Unions did not argue for membersâ vaccination choices that emphasized personal autonomy and medical privacy. When employees who were unvaccinated were escorted from the workplace, unions did not defend the employeesâ rights. Witnesses said their filed grievances were not heard. Legal and ethical issues were not considered when the COVID vaccinations were introduced. The balancing of collective and individual interests, normally advocated for by unions, was not strived for. Unions did not advocate for employer policies that protect public health and respect workersâ rights. As alluded to in witness testimony, regulatory bodies were determined to control members who questioned COVID mandates. This was particularly true in healthcare, but other witnesses told of similar actions in their own regulatory professions as well. It was observed from the testimony that many of the actions taken by the respective regulatory bodies may have gone beyond the scope of their authority. This was not a first-time occurrence for the College of Physicians and Surgeons in Ontario. In a similar context, it should be noted that the Alberta courts in the Shelia Lewis organ transplant case went to great lengths to protect the coveted doctorâclient privilege. The Honourable Judge R. Paul Belzil opined that in the view of the court, it is not necessary for treating officials to reconcile differences in expert opinions, but rather physicians must be free to decide which expert opinions they accept in exercising their clinical judgment which informs the standard of care. And yet many highly educated and qualified professionals, among them physicians and surgeons, who spoke publicly against government-imposed mandatesâincluding COVID vaccines and/or governmentsâ responses to COVIDâwere subject to disciplinary actions initiated by their own professional regulatory bodies. Dissenting viewpoints were suppressed; physicians were made examples of in order to prevent other doctors from raising concerns too. Moreover, one physician testified to his willingness to lose his livelihood and professional credentials to warn the populace of the potential dangers of COVID-19 vaccinations. The fact that an increasing number of medical physicians are being systematically suspended, disciplined, or professionally removed from their positions cannot be ignored. As the testimony revealed, the respective colleges appeared to have turned investigations into fishing expeditions. In one example, the college went so far as to seize patient files from the doctorâs office. Still, not one of these accused healthcare professionals harmed or caused the untimely death of a patient. Ethics in the medical context includes Informed Consent. This did not happen. Governing authorities passed legislation that absolved pharmaceutical companies from wrongdoing. This meant pharmaceuticals were no longer accountable to the Canadian public for adverse medical reactions, undue harm, or death. Moreover, the clinical trials for COVID-19 vaccines are ongoing, so ethically, how could health authorities and governments condone the vaccines as safe and effective? Both economically and socially, COVID presented significant challenges. So-called quiet quitting was an emerging trend that appeared to gain momentum as the mandates increased. It was almost as if Canadians were entering their homes and closing the door to the outside world once and for all. Business operations were defined by bureaucrats as either essential or non-essential. Many people lost their jobs. Households faced reduced income. Family businesses that had weathered previous economic downturns were forced to close while big-box stores and government-sponsored businesses remained open. Building-size regulations or fire code occupancy authorizations were not used as a standard for determining gathering numbers. From witness testimony, Costco was allowed 818 customers in the store at the same time, while businesses and churches with similar size facilities were restricted to ten. The reduction in businesses led to decreased choices in consumer purchasing. For businesses forced to close, there was financial distress and economic hardship. The goal of science is the pursuit of knowledge--not necessarily the pursuit of truth. There is a distinction. When the public follows the science, there is a shifting alliance from the supremacy of God to the supremacy of science. But science changes over time. It is not constant, which is part of the attraction to the discipline of science. Consider the Milgram experiments, the rationale of conscientious objectors, and the various scenarios like electroshock treatments that led to the establishment of professional ethical standards, such as the Tri-Council. Religious and medical exemptions have long been accepted as forms of accommodation in Western democracies. This apparently changed during COVID, when the decision-makers for employment insurance (EI), for example, universally disallowed EI benefits to unvaccinated claimants. Given that the EI program is sustained through payroll deductions of employers and employees, the federal government does not have the legal, moral, or ethical authority to suggest the decision to reject exemptions are about balancing individual rights with the public interests. These civil employees are not qualified to determine the legitimacy of exemptions either. Why not? Because EI is not funded by the federal government. The other point worth noting here is that these same employees are not hired to challenge the legitimacy of medical or religious exemptions. Public service employees are hired to perform their duties according to the legislation that governs their responsibilities. There is no discretion in the legislation. EI as public policy is intended to provide Canadians with income when their employment circumstances change. It should also be noted that limiting exemptions, is not a legal, moral, or ethical way for increasing vaccination rates within the broader community. It borders on coercion, which in and of itself is illegal in the public square, and this becomes more egregious when demanded as a program requirement from government employees. This brings the conversation directly to the Canada Emergency Response Benefit (CERB), the Canada Recovery Benefit (CRB), the Canada Recovery Sickness Benefit (CRSB), the Canada Recovery Caregiving Benefit (CRCB), and the other forms of government compensation handouts during COVID. CERB was considered a key financial support program introduced by the federal government to provide financial assistance to individuals who were directly affected by the pandemic and lost income as a result of job loss, quarantine, caregiving responsibilities, or reduced working hours. This begs an obvious question: How can employees who contribute their hard-earned income to payroll deductions (which includes EI premiums) be denied insurance benefits for choosing not to be vaccinated, and yet, the federal government can dole out public funds with no questions asked? It is no wonder the Lord says the right hand of government does not know what the left hand is doing. This could explain why civil liberties groups criticize the discriminatory acts of governments or why the truckers at the Freedom Convoy stood their ground in Ottawa and Windsor, Ontario, and Coutts, Alberta. Because all levels of government and health authorities, including elected and non-elected officials, arbitrarily put onerous restrictions on the movement or peaceful assembly of citizens within the public square. Indeed, the governing authorities went too far when they infringed on individual freedoms. As the testimony revealed, these same governing authorities condoned bending a knee for Black Lives Matter and other groups during COVID mandates, but then threatened the truckers and attendees at churches and funerals with hefty fines and jail time. Besides heavy-handed bullying, the police services in Canada did not follow their own emergency plans or established protocols. There was no pursuit of justice for the greater good, either. Section 7 of the Charterâwhich guarantees life, liberty, and securityâwas discarded, as were many other constitutional provisions. As Canadians witnessed, governments at all levels continued pursuing their objectives throughout the pandemic. Political legislation was still being put forward. The public service was still employed. Bureaucrats remained nameless. Justice was behind a screen, wherein only the privileged could obtain access. In the process, governments continued to award contracts to businesses that health authorities deemed essential. It would be difficult to deny the obvious patronage and nepotism. In the example of drug stores, witness testimony alluded to contracts awarded to administer COVID vaccinations outside of a fair and open tendering process that provided every entity, business, or organization with the same opportunities. The administrative state continued playing games with citizensâ livesâbecause at no point were these employees held accountable for wrongdoing. Nevertheless, when someone points the finger at citizens, there are three fingers pointing back at them. Governments, like the people, are bound by the law. Governments cannot just decide which laws are to be obeyed and which are to be disregarded. Throughout COVID, there were winners and losersâeach declared by the same governing officials who were elected to represent the publicâs best interests but did not. There was excessive power imposed by authority figures against hardworking Canadians: police versus citizen, teacher versus student, employer versus employee, judge versus accused, elected official versus constituent, vaccinated versus unvaccinated. Is this the trickle-down effect of passive-aggression? Or is it simply the governmentsâ method for crumbling a democracy from the inside out? Regardless, the same application of the law for citizens did not apply equally to those in privileged positions of power. And there was no accountability or transparency. As numerous witnesses shared, ordinary citizens were arrested and detained in jail cells for standing firmly on the rights and freedoms established in the Constitution Act of 1867 , the Charter, and the Bill of Rights . Churches were seized. The RCMP sent canine units to hunt for peaceful churchgoers. Truckers participating in the Freedom Convoy had assets seized. And so did a retired Ontario Provincial Police officer for facilitating dialogue between the truckers and governing administrators. Did anyone ask: Where was the presumption of innocence? Or what happened in Canada that negated the administration of justice? Who is responsible for adhering to the Precautionary Principle in public policy making, which should have legitimized the adoption of preventive measures to address potential risks to the public? Who is the ultimate judge when egregious actions should lead to liability, but there is no public recourse? Who lied? Perhaps the country can take a lesson from witness Steve Kirsch, who said, âThe state has manipulated your mind; once you are willing to question your beliefs, everything else makes sense.â This is not to suggest there are not some glimmers of hope. The Ingram legal case in Alberta is most certainly a step forward for democracy and justice. Citizens are awakening to the repeated propaganda and messaging that consumed the airwaves over the three COVID years. Critical questions are being asked. And over 300 brave souls, Canadian citizens who believe in standing up for what is right and just and true, shared their personal testimony so that this nation, from shining sea to sea to sea, could be restored from the clutches of schoolyard bullies in adult bodies who need to understand, first, the meaning of good governance before sitting in positions of privilege. American writer, novelist, and Pulitzer Prize winner Pearl Buck (1892â1973) described the true essence of society in this way: âOur society must make it right and possible for old people not to fear the young or to be deserted by them, for the test of a civilization is the way that it cares for its helpless members.â United States Vice-President Hubert Humphrey carried Ms. Buckâs thought one step further when he said, âThe moral test of government is how government treats those who are in the dawn of life, the children; those who are in the twilight of life, the elderly; those who are in the shadows of life: the sick, the needy, and the disabled.â Or, as Jesus so aptly said in the synagogue in Nazareth, âThe Spirit of the Lord is upon Me, because He hath anointed Me to proclaim good news to the poor. He has sent Me to proclaim liberty to the captives and recovering of sight to the blind, to set at liberty those who are oppressed, to proclaim the year of the Lordâs favour.â This is the ultimate mission field for all Canadians to pursue, and in so doing, let the brave NCI witnesses and the truckers in the Freedom Convoy join the many other Canadian voices that understand real answers are not found in rationalizing logic (because as we have observed over the COVID Years, logic too often turns into evil), but rather in shining brightly in one accord, so we too, as proud Canadians, can adamantly declare, âNever again.â Recommendations The discussion raises important concerns about the negative impacts of the federal governmentâs pandemic response on the fabric of Canadian society. These impacts encompass a wide range of areas, from personal freedoms and trust in institutions to economic, social, and health consequences. To prevent such issues from happening in the future, we put forth the following 12 recommendations. National Crisis Oversight Council : Commission a study to determine the validity of setting up a National Crisis Oversight Council (NCOC), with a rationale and expected format as follows: Rationale Establishing the NCOC is essential to safeguarding democratic principles, protecting individual rights, and maintaining public trust during future emergencies, such as pandemics. The NCOC will serve as an independent, multidisciplinary body tasked with monitoring, policing, and investigating government actions during crises. Basic Characteristics and Principles Representation: The NCOC will comprise representatives from diverse sectors of society, including law, medicine, science, faith, business, media, arts, and culture. Each member will undergo a public appointment process, with credentials and potential conflicts of interest transparently disclosed. Subpoena powers: The council will possess subpoena powers, allowing it to compel testimony and evidence from all sectors, including government officials, the judiciary, and other relevant stakeholders. Public access: To ensure transparency and accountability, the NCOC will offer the public direct and unfiltered access. A user-friendly platform will enable citizens to express concerns, provide observations, and access council proceedings. Legislative clarity: The powers and responsibilities of the NCOC will be clearly outlined in legislation, eliminating the need for regulatory details to be determined separately. This legal foundation will establish the councilâs authority and scope. Empowerment for change: The NCOC will have mechanisms to influence government actions during emergencies. It will be empowered to make recommendations, demand corrective actions, and trigger public awareness campaigns when necessary. Its primary goal will be to uphold democratic values and individual rights and freedoms, and help ensure the wellbeing of citizens. Media access: The council will be expected to have unrestricted access to all forms of media to maintain public trust and transparency. Regular briefings, reports, and public statements will keep citizens informed of its activities and findings. Purpose and Benefits The NCOC would be founded on the principle that a robust system of checks and balances is vital in times of crisis. Its purpose would be to: Safeguard democracy: Ensure that democratic principles are upheld during emergencies, preventing overreach and abuse of power. Protect individual rights: Safeguard citizensâ fundamental rights and liberties, even when extraordinary measures are deemed necessary. Maintain public trust: Enhance transparency and accountability in government actions, fostering public confidence in crisis management. Promote evidence-based decisions: Encourage government responses to be grounded in science, data, and expert advice. Support effective governance: Assist in identifying gaps and weaknesses in government responsesâleading to more effective crisis management. Advance public discourse: Facilitate open dialogue between government, experts, and the public to promote informed decision-making. In summary, the establishment of the NCOC would be a proactive response to ensure that during future emergencies, the rights and values of Canadian society are upheld. It strengthens democracy, promotes transparency, and empowers the public to actively participate in safeguarding their wellbeing and fundamental rights. Transparency and honest communication : Governments should prioritize transparent and honest communication with the public during crises. Information about the nature of the crisis, measures being taken, and the expected duration of those measures should be clearly and consistently conveyed. Accountability mechanisms : Establish mechanisms for holding public officials accountable for their decisions during crises. This includes oversight bodies that can review actions taken by governments and ensure they align with constitutional rights and freedoms. Respect for constitutional rights : Safeguard constitutional rights and freedoms, even during emergencies. Governments should not infringe on these rights without clear and justifiable reasons, and any restrictions should be proportional and time-limited. Balanced approach : Develop and implement a balanced approach to crisis management that considers public health alongside economic, social, and mental wellbeing. Decisions should be evidence-based and consider the broad spectrum of societal impacts. Community engagement : Engage with communities, civil society organizations, and a wide range of experts in decision-making processes. Encourage open dialogue and ensure that policies and measures are sensitive to the unique needs and circumstances of different groups within society. Education and awareness : Promote public education and awareness about public health measures, their rationale, and the expected outcomes. Informed citizens are more likely to be able to make informed decisions and hold officials accountable for their actions. Support for vulnerable populations : Develop strategies to support vulnerable populations during crisesâsuch as the homeless, those struggling with addiction, and victims of domestic abuse. Ensure that access to essential services is maintained. Healthcare infrastructure : Invest in and strengthen healthcare infrastructure to ensure capacity and readiness for future public health emergencies. This includes resources for mental health services, addiction treatment, and domestic violence support. Mandatory ethics training for health care workers : To enhance the ethical standards and ensure the protection of fundamental patient rights and access to care, we strongly recommend the implementation of annual mandatory ethics training for all healthcare workers. This training should apply to frontline, administrative, and managerial staff across the healthcare system, resulting in the following benefits: Ethical awareness: Annual ethics training will promote awareness of ethical principles, ensuring that all healthcare workers have a comprehensive understanding of their ethical responsibilities toward patients, colleagues, family members, and the healthcare system as a whole. Patient-centred care: Ethical training will underscore the importance of prioritizing patientsâ wellbeing, rights, and dignity in all healthcare decisions and actions. It will reinforce the commitment to patient-centred care. Legal and regulatory compliance: Ethical training will help healthcare workers understand and comply with legal and regulatory requirements related to patient rights and access to care, reducing the likelihood of breaches and legal issues. Improved communication: Ethical training can enhance communication skills, fostering open and honest dialogue with patients and their families. This will contribute to better-informed decision-making and greater patient satisfaction. Crisis preparedness: In times of crises like the COVID-19 pandemic, healthcare workers will be better prepared to make difficult ethical decisions under pressure, ensuring that patient rights and access to care are upheld even in challenging circumstances. Accountability: Mandatory training establishes clear expectations and accountability for ethical behaviour. It provides a basis for addressing breaches and taking corrective actions promptly. Continual improvement: Annual training allows healthcare workers to stay updated on evolving ethical guidelines and best practices, facilitating a culture of continual improvement in patient care. Organizational culture: Ethical training can contribute to building a culture of respect, compassion, and integrity within healthcare institutions, benefiting both patients and staff. Scientific integrity : Protect the integrity of scientific research and expert opinions. Encourage open debate and diverse perspectives within the scientific community to ensure that policy decisions are well informed. Legislative safeguards : Review and update emergency powers legislation to strike a balance between swift response and protection of individual rights. Ensure that such powers are subject to regular parliamentary review and oversight. In essence, the goal is to develop a comprehensive strategy that prioritizes the health and wellbeing of citizens while respecting democratic values, individual rights, and the resilience of Canadian society as a whole. These recommendations aim to foster a society where crises are managed with care, accountability, and a commitment to the long-term welfare of all citizens. Report Content Reader Page đ Note to Readers The content presented on this page has been adapted for online viewing and navigation. Due to formatting limitations within the web display system, certain elementsâsuch as layout, spacing, and visual structureâmay differ slightly from the original report. For the complete and fully formatted version, we encourage you to download the official PDF available on the Report Information page. The PDF reflects the report exactly as it was originally written and published.
- McCullough | National Citizens Ar
Detailed Commissioner Report Info Referenced in the Report National Citizens Inquiry (NCI) Investigation: Are Children Safe in Canada April 30, 2025 Report ID: Publication Date No. Of Pages: NCI-R-04 April 30, 2024 1267 March 16, 2023 Report National Citizens Inquiry (NCI) Investigation: Are Children Safe in Canada April 30, 2025 Main Topic Purpose and Need for the NCI The National Citizens Inquiry (NCI) was established in response to growing public concerns over the Canadian governmentâs handling of the COVID-19 event. As the COVID-19 emergency measures unfolded, questions arose regarding the appropriateness and efficacy of the measures implemented, including lockdowns, mandates, and the deployment of COVID-19 âvaccines.â These concerns fuelled the need for a thorough examination of the impact these policies had on health, the economy, on society and civil liberties. The NCI, conceived as an independent and citizen led initiative, sought to comprehensively investigate these issues. Its primary purpose was to provide a platform for individuals and experts to share their experiences, insights, and evidence, in order to uncover the truth, hold authorities accountable, and improve future public health responses. On November 28, 2023, the NCI Commissioners released their comprehensive final report, titled Inquiry into the Appropriateness and Efficacy of the COVID-19 Response in Canada . A year later, on November 28, 2024, a supplemental report was issued as part of the NCIâs ongoing efforts to address new and emerging concerns related to the COVID-19 investigation. Having completed its original mandate of investigating the appropriateness and efficacy of the COVID-19 measures, the NCI expanded its focus. After consulting with a broad range of Canadians, the NCI recognized a significant public concern regarding the current state of children's safety in Canada. Consequently, the NCI undertook a new investigation specifically aimed at evaluating and safeguarding the well-being of children across the country. One Line Summary Heading 2 Synopsis Heading 2
- NCI-R-03-Item-5-2-1 | National Citizens Ar
5.2.1 Neglect & Isolation of Seniors Amidst COVID-19 Interventions 5.2 Social Impacts 5.2.1 Neglect & Isolation of Seniors Amidst COVID-19 Interventions Introduction This topic was included in the original November 28, 2023 NCI Report as section 7.2.1 Neglect and Isolation of Seniors in Canada Amidst COVID-19 Interventions. Witness Testimony Additional testimonies were received from witnesses working within long-term care facilities during the time that the COVID-19 interventions were implemented. Testimonies were received from the following witnesses: Allison Nesdoly Ms. Nesdoly is a licensed practical nurse who worked in several long-term senior care facilities during the pandemic, where she was responsible for providing direct care to patients. She continued working in these facilities following the rollout of the vaccination program in 2021. During this time, she observed a noticeable decline in the health of many patients after they received the COVID-19 vaccines. This decline manifested in various forms which included rashes, pain, and an overall deterioration in both physical and cognitive health. Ms. Nesdoly also observed that shortly after each round of vaccinations there would be an outbreak of COVID-19 and Respiratory Syncytial Virus (RSV) within the facility. These outbreaks typically occurred within a week of the vaccinations. She testified that many of the residents had received multiple doses of the vaccine. Despite being vaccinated multiple times, the residents were subjected to lockdowns and isolation whenever there was an outbreak in the facility. These lockdowns lasted from several days to weeks, and Ms. Nesdoly noted that the periods of forced isolation had a profoundly negative impact on the residentsâ well being. Ms. Nesdoly herself chose not to be vaccinated based on her own research and her history of adverse reactions to previous vaccines. She also noted that her colleagues experienced various side effects following their COVID-19 vaccinations. These included rashes, skin lumps, open sores, and headaches. Alarmingly, two nurses suffered seizures shortly after receiving the vaccine. Many of her co-workers discussed these issues among themselves, expressing concerns about the effects they were experiencing. Ms. Nesdolyâs testimony highlights the troubling health impacts observed in both residents and staff in long-term care facilities following COVID-19 vaccinations, as well as the detrimental effects of repeated lockdowns and isolation on vulnerable populations. Sheena Clarke Ms. Clarke is a registered nurse from New Brunswick who had extensive experience working in two local hospitals across most departments until 2017, when she transitioned to long-term home care. During the pandemic she observed widespread fear and depression among residents in the long-term care facilities where she worked. She described how many patients felt so lonely that they expressed a desire to die, with some residents even sleeping with their masks on out of fear. Despite the pervasive fear, there were no COVID-19 infections in her facility. However, within days and weeks of the vaccination rollout, Ms. Clarke observed a troubling increase in health issues among residents. These issues included shortness of breath, chest pains, seizures, blood clots, heart attacks, herpes, shingles, and strokes. Alarmingly, some elderly women even began menstruating. As time passed, the number of complaints related to these issues grew, as did the frequency of these adverse events following vaccination. Ms. Clarke also noticed significant changes in patientsâ blood analyses after they received the vaccine. Concerned about these developments, she reported her observations regarding the negative effects of the measures on residents. She was instructed to add her concerns to the âDoctorâs Board.â However, when she reported these issues, she was informed that the only recognized side effects of the vaccines were anaphylaxis and arm pain. She was told she was not authorized to report these issues since she was not the designated person responsible for such reports. Furthermore, she was instructed to stop reporting her findings because they were causing alarm among the staff. Ms. Clarke took her concerns to various regulatory bodies, including her union, but found little support. The staff in her facility were also living in fear, facing constant revisions to the rules that governed their work. The availability and adequacy of personal protective equipment (PPE) and operational requirements were frequently changing, often in ways that seemed illogical. Although Ms. Clarke herself was not vaccinated and had received an exemption, she was ultimately terminated when vaccine mandates were implemented. Her testimony underscores the profound challenges and distress faced by both residents and healthcare workers in long-term care during the pandemic. Sarah Choujounian Ms. Choujounian, a registered practical nurse, worked during the pandemic in both a nursing home and with children in the community. As the chief steward of her union, she raised concerns about the loss of rights experienced by both staff and patients during this period. However, the union advised her to comply with the pandemic measures. She observed that the lockdowns and other restrictions had significant negative effects on the residents of the nursing home. Deprived of family visits, many residents began to âfail to thrive.â Ms. Choujounian stated that these negative outcomes were predictable, given the severity of the measures being implemented. Fourteen-day lockdowns were enforced, and some residents became increasingly agitated, leading to the sedation of many individuals. If any resident tested positive for COVID-19, regardless of whether they showed symptoms, the lockdowns were extended by an additional 14 days. Ms. Choujounian noted that doctors did not visit the facility to observe the situation firsthand, and she had no direct access to report her observations to them. She also pointed out that no representatives from regulatory bodies visited the facility to monitor the conditions. There were no daily meetings or discussions to assess the situation within the facility or to evaluate the impact of the measures on the residents. All rehabilitation and physical therapy services were halted, further exacerbating the residentsâ decline. Despite the troubling conditions, no one within the facility voiced complaints, and no Informed Consent was obtained before altering the residentsâ treatment schedules. Concerned about what she was witnessing, Ms. Choujounian began sharing her observations with a private group on social media. As a result, she was placed under investigation for her posts. After speaking at a public hearing, Ms. Choujounian was terminated from her employment. Her testimony underscores the severe impact of the pandemic measures on vulnerable nursing home residents and the lack of oversight or accountability within the facility. Discussion of NCI 2023 Report Section 7.2.1 of the original 2023 NCI Report addresses the overall impact of COVID-19 lockdowns on seniors in long-term care facilities. The section highlights issues such as isolation, mental health deterioration, and inadequate medical care. Key points include: Increased isolation due to lockdown measures leading to mental health issues like depression and anxiety. Limited physical activity and rehabilitation services causing physical decline. Challenges with maintaining adequate staffing levels and PPE. Lack of regular medical oversight and insufficient reporting of adverse events. Summary of New Testimonies Allison Nesdoly (Regina, SK) Observations on Health Post-Vaccination : Patients experienced deterioration in health that included rashes, pain, cognitive and physical decline post-vaccination. Noted outbreaks of COVID-19 and RSV shortly after vaccinations. Staff Health Issues : Staff experienced rashes, skin lumps, open sores, headaches, and seizures following vaccination. Isolation Impact : Frequent lockdowns, regardless of vaccination status, negatively impacted residentsâ well being. Personal Vaccine Hesitancy : Chose not to vaccinate due to personal history and research. Sheena Clarke (Regina, SK) Observations on Health Post-Vaccination : Increased incidence of shortness of breath, chest pains, seizures, blood clots, heart attacks, and other serious health issues post-vaccination. Blood analyses showed changes post-vaccination. Isolation and Fear : High levels of fear and depression among residents; some wore masks even while sleeping. Staff lived in fear due to constantly changing rules and PPE shortages. Reporting Issues : Faced resistance when reporting adverse effects and was eventually terminated for vaccine non-compliance despite having an exemption. Sarah Choujounian (Regina, SK) Union and Reporting Challenges : Reported concerns about loss of rights to the union; and was instructed to comply with pandemic measures. Negative Effects of Lockdowns : Lockdowns led to significant negative impacts, including residents being deprived of family visits, sedation of agitated residents, and a halt to rehabilitation services. Lack of Medical Oversight : Doctors did not visit the facility, and there were no regulatory checks or Informed Consent for treatment changes. Social Media and Termination : Posted observations on social media and was investigated and terminated after speaking publicly. Additional Critical Information from New Testimonies Health Deterioration Post-Vaccination: New testimonies provide specific details on the physical and cognitive decline of residents, post-vaccination, including severe side effects like seizures, blood clots, heart attacks, and even menstruation in elderly women. Mention of outbreaks of COVID-19 and RSV following vaccinations added a new layer to the understanding of post-vaccination effects. Staff Health and Vaccine Reactions: Reports of adverse reactions among staff that included rashes, headaches, and seizures which were not covered in the original report. Reporting and Oversight Failures: Detailed instances of obstructed reporting with staff being instructed not to report issues and facing termination for non-compliance or speaking out. Lack of medical oversight and regulatory visits highlighted that showed a systemic failure in monitoring and addressing the issues within facilities. Impact of Isolation and Lockdowns: Specifics on the duration and frequency of lockdowns and their severe impact on residentsâ mental health and physical well being. Description of the negative consequences of isolation, including the increased use of sedation and the halting of rehabilitation services, provided a deeper understanding of the adverse effects of lockdown measures. Personal Experiences and Professional Risks: Personal accounts of facing professional risks for not complying with vaccination mandates or for speaking out against the observed issues. Testimonies provide a human elementâshowing the fear and frustration experienced by both residents and staff during the pandemic. Overall, the new testimonies offer a more detailed and nuanced picture of the challenges faced by seniors and healthcare workers during the COVID-19 pandemic by highlighting significant gaps in care, oversight, and the negative impact of both vaccination and lockdown measures. Conclusion Based on the new information provided in the three testimonies from Allison Nesdoly, Sheena Clarke, and Sarah Choujounian, the following additional conclusions can be drawn beyond those made in the original NCI Report: Post-Vaccination Health Decline: There is a noticeable and concerning pattern of health deterioration in both residents and staff following COVID-19 lockdowns and vaccinationsâincluding severe physical and cognitive declinesâwhich was not fully addressed in the original report. The testimonies suggest a potential correlation between the vaccinations and subsequent outbreaks of COVID-19 and RSV, indicating a need for further investigation into the timing and nature of these outbreaks. Adverse Effects Among Staff: The adverse effects of vaccinations on healthcare staff, including serious conditions like seizures and persistent skin issues, were not highlighted in the original report. This underscores the broader impact of the pandemic measures on the entire healthcare ecosystem, not just the residents. Staff experiencing these effects may have implications for the quality of care provided, as their own health issues can impact their ability to perform their duties effectively. Systemic Reporting and Oversight Failures: The systemic failure to properly report, acknowledge, and address adverse health effects post-vaccination is a significant concern. This includes the suppression of staff reports and the lack of proper channels for reporting these issues. The lack of regulatory oversight and visits to the facilities indicates a failure in the monitoring systems intended to safeguard the health and well being of residents. Negative Impact of Isolation and Lockdowns: The detrimental effects of prolonged isolation and repeated lockdowns on residentsâ mental and physical health were more severe than previously documented. The testimonies provide concrete examples of depression, increased agitation, and the use of sedation as a consequence of these measures. The testimonies also reveal that lockdowns continued despite high vaccination rates among residents, which questions the efficacy and rationale behind such stringent measures. Professional and Ethical Challenges: The testimonies highlight significant ethical and professional challenges faced by healthcare workers, including the conflict between following directives and advocating for patient well being. The professional risks faced by healthcare workers for raising concerns or refusing vaccination mandates reveal a climate of fear and suppression that likely affected the overall quality of care. Impact on Rehabilitation and Long-term Health: The cessation of rehabilitation and physical therapies, as described in the testimonies, indicates a long-term impact on residentsâ physical health that may not have been fully appreciated in the original report. The lack of Informed Consent for changes in treatment schedules raises serious ethical concerns and indicates a potential violation of residentsâ rights. Need for Comprehensive Review and Policy Adjustment: The new information calls for a comprehensive review of the policies and measures implemented during the pandemic, particularly around vaccination, lockdowns, and isolation protocols. There is a clear need for establishing better reporting mechanisms and ensuring transparency and accountability in handling adverse health effects and other issues arising from pandemic measures. Holistic Support for Healthcare Workers: The testimonies underline the necessity for better support systems for healthcare workers, including mental health support, clear communication, and fair treatment in the face of adverse reactions or professional disagreements regarding pandemic measures. In conclusion, the new testimonies provide critical insights that highlight the need for a more nuanced and responsive approach to handling pandemics in long-term care facilities, emphasizing the importance of balancing infection control measures with the overall well being of both residents and staff. Recommendations Considering the new information provided by Allison Nesdoly, Sheena Clarke, and Sarah Choujounian, the following additional recommendations are proposed: Comprehensive Adverse Effect Reporting System: Develop a mandatory, anonymous reporting system for adverse health effects following vaccinations or other medical interventions. Ensure that all reports are investigated promptly and thoroughly. Establish an independent committee to review and address these reports, ensuring transparency and accountability. 2. Improved Oversight and Accountability: Introduce regular, unannounced visits by independent medical professionals and regulatory bodies to monitor the health and safety of residents and staff. Ensure these visits include assessments of mental health and the overall well being of residents. 3. Support for Healthcare Workers: Provide mental health support and counselling services for healthcare workers to address the psychological impact of their work during the pandemic. Implement policies to protect workers from retaliation when they raise legitimate health and safety concerns, thereby fostering a culture of openness and support. 4. Re-evaluation and Adjustment of Vaccination Policies: Conduct independent studies to evaluate the long-term effects of COVID-19 vaccinations on both residents and staff. Use the findings to adjust vaccination policies to minimize adverse effects. Develop protocols for monitoring and managing vaccine side effectsâensuring timely and appropriate medical responses. 5. Ethical Treatment and Informed Consent: Ensure that Informed Consent is obtained from residents or their guardians before making significant changes to their treatment or care routines. Establish ethics committees within facilities to review and oversee decisions related to resident care during emergencies to safeguard ethical standards are upheld. 6. Balanced Approach to Isolation and Lockdowns: Implement targeted isolation measures that minimize disruption to residentsâ daily lives while effectively controlling infections. Explore alternatives to lockdowns that allow for safe social interactions. Introduce regular, safe social activities and family visits to reduce the negative impact of isolation on residentsâ mental health. 7. Continuation of Rehabilitation and Therapy Services: Ensure that rehabilitation and physical therapy services continue to be available even during pandemics, recognizing their importance in maintaining residentsâ physical health and overall well being. Develop protocols to safely conduct these services during health crises. 8. Training on Ethical Decision-Making: Provide training for healthcare workers on ethical decision-making and residentsâ rights, empowering them to make informed and compassionate care decisions. Include training on managing and reporting adverse vaccine reactions and other health crises. 9. Enhanced Communication and Transparency: Develop clear and consistent communication channels to keep residents, families, and staff informed about the measures being implemented and any changes in policies. Facilitate regular updates and meetings to address concerns and provide reassurance to ensure all parties are well-informed and involved in decision-making processes. 10. Public Health and Policy Adjustments: Review and adjust public health policies based on emerging data and feedback from frontline workers and residents to warrant they are effective and humane. Ensure policies are flexible and can be adapted quickly in response to new information or changing circumstances. By incorporating these additional recommendations, long-term care facilities can provide a more comprehensive, ethical, and effective response to future pandemics, ultimately leading to better health outcomes and improved well being for both residents and staff. Report Content Reader Page đ Note to Readers The content presented on this page has been adapted for online viewing and navigation. Due to formatting limitations within the web display system, certain elementsâsuch as layout, spacing, and visual structureâmay differ slightly from the original report. For the complete and fully formatted version, we encourage you to download the official PDF available on the Report Information page. The PDF reflects the report exactly as it was originally written and published.
- Vossen | National Citizens Ar
Detailed Commissioner Report Info Referenced in the Report National Citizens Inquiry (NCI) Investigation: Are Children Safe in Canada April 30, 2025 Report ID: Publication Date No. Of Pages: NCI-R-04 April 30, 2024 1267 April 15, 2023 Report National Citizens Inquiry (NCI) Investigation: Are Children Safe in Canada April 30, 2025 Main Topic Purpose and Need for the NCI The National Citizens Inquiry (NCI) was established in response to growing public concerns over the Canadian governmentâs handling of the COVID-19 event. As the COVID-19 emergency measures unfolded, questions arose regarding the appropriateness and efficacy of the measures implemented, including lockdowns, mandates, and the deployment of COVID-19 âvaccines.â These concerns fuelled the need for a thorough examination of the impact these policies had on health, the economy, on society and civil liberties. The NCI, conceived as an independent and citizen led initiative, sought to comprehensively investigate these issues. Its primary purpose was to provide a platform for individuals and experts to share their experiences, insights, and evidence, in order to uncover the truth, hold authorities accountable, and improve future public health responses. On November 28, 2023, the NCI Commissioners released their comprehensive final report, titled Inquiry into the Appropriateness and Efficacy of the COVID-19 Response in Canada . A year later, on November 28, 2024, a supplemental report was issued as part of the NCIâs ongoing efforts to address new and emerging concerns related to the COVID-19 investigation. Having completed its original mandate of investigating the appropriateness and efficacy of the COVID-19 measures, the NCI expanded its focus. After consulting with a broad range of Canadians, the NCI recognized a significant public concern regarding the current state of children's safety in Canada. Consequently, the NCI undertook a new investigation specifically aimed at evaluating and safeguarding the well-being of children across the country. One Line Summary Heading 2 Synopsis Heading 2
- Clarke | National Citizens Ar
Witness Testimony Keywords from Transcript Province of Nova Scotia Employee, Department of Education and Early Childhood Development, Vaccine Mandate Employment Requirement, NSGEU Union Communication, No Exemption Sought, Coercion Perception, Employment Ultimatum, Autonomy Loss, Anxiety and Trauma, Gravesâ Disease Disclosure, Pharmacist Administration, Pfizer Vaccine, Lot FF5109, Independent Grocer Hubbards, Spousal Vaccine Injury, Pulmonary Embolism (Spouse), Financial Hardship, Income Interruption, Unemployment Insurance Gap, Workplace Accommodation (New Employer), Trust in Government Loss Included in the Report: Ms. Tami Clarke Public Service Coordinator Both (Personal and Employment Experience) Witness ID: NCI-W-038 Hearing Truro Nova Scotia Date: March 18, 2023 Report Inquiry into the Appropriateness and Efficacy of the COVID-19 Response in Canada; November 2023 Main Topic Vaccine Mandate Compliance Under Employment Pressure and Family Impact Following Spousal Vaccine Injury One Line Summary Public service coordinator Tami Clarke testified that she felt compelled to receive two Pfizer doses under provincial employment mandate despite her spouseâs recent vaccine-related pulmonary embolism, resulting in psychological distress and financial strain. Synopsis Tami Clarke testified that she was employed as a coordinator for transcripts and international programs within the Nova Scotia Department of Education and Early Childhood Development. She stated that her work involved a small internal team and no direct public interaction. Following her spouse Kirk Desrosiersâ hospitalization for bilateral pulmonary emboli after vaccination, she was required under provincial mandate to be vaccinated to retain her employment. She testified that she did not seek a formal exemption, believing such requests were routinely denied, and described the choice as either vaccination or unemployment. Clarke received her first Pfizer dose on November 24, 2021 (lot FF5109) and her second dose on January 18, 2022 (same lot number), administered by a pharmacist at an Independent Grocer in Hubbards, Nova Scotia. She disclosed her Gravesâ disease diagnosis at the time of vaccination but testified that no individualized risk assessment was conducted beyond standard screening. She reported no physical side effects but described significant anxiety and psychological trauma associated with being vaccinated shortly after her spouseâs diagnosis. She testified that her husband experienced a 120-day period without income between unemployment benefits and disability coverage, creating financial hardship that required the family to make significant lifestyle adjustments. Clarke stated that she later obtained employment closer to home with an employer who allowed accommodation when her spouseâs health required her presence. She described a loss of trust in public institutions and feelings of coercion related to the mandate. đ How to Search the Transcript Click the âRead Transcriptâ button to open the witness testimony in your browser. Once the transcript PDF is open, you can search for any word or phrase within the document using your browserâs search feature: Windows: Press Ctrl + F Mac: Press Command (â) + F A small search box will appear. Type the word or phrase you are looking for, and the browser will highlight every occurrence within the transcript. This makes it easy to quickly locate specific topics, names, or statements within the testimony.
- Marazzo | National Citizens Ar
Detailed Commissioner Report Info Referenced in the Report National Citizens Inquiry (NCI) Investigation: Are Children Safe in Canada April 30, 2025 Report ID: Publication Date No. Of Pages: NCI-R-04 April 30, 2024 1267 March 31, 2023 Report National Citizens Inquiry (NCI) Investigation: Are Children Safe in Canada April 30, 2025 Main Topic Purpose and Need for the NCI The National Citizens Inquiry (NCI) was established in response to growing public concerns over the Canadian governmentâs handling of the COVID-19 event. As the COVID-19 emergency measures unfolded, questions arose regarding the appropriateness and efficacy of the measures implemented, including lockdowns, mandates, and the deployment of COVID-19 âvaccines.â These concerns fuelled the need for a thorough examination of the impact these policies had on health, the economy, on society and civil liberties. The NCI, conceived as an independent and citizen led initiative, sought to comprehensively investigate these issues. Its primary purpose was to provide a platform for individuals and experts to share their experiences, insights, and evidence, in order to uncover the truth, hold authorities accountable, and improve future public health responses. On November 28, 2023, the NCI Commissioners released their comprehensive final report, titled Inquiry into the Appropriateness and Efficacy of the COVID-19 Response in Canada . A year later, on November 28, 2024, a supplemental report was issued as part of the NCIâs ongoing efforts to address new and emerging concerns related to the COVID-19 investigation. Having completed its original mandate of investigating the appropriateness and efficacy of the COVID-19 measures, the NCI expanded its focus. After consulting with a broad range of Canadians, the NCI recognized a significant public concern regarding the current state of children's safety in Canada. Consequently, the NCI undertook a new investigation specifically aimed at evaluating and safeguarding the well-being of children across the country. One Line Summary Heading 2 Synopsis Heading 2
- Blauvelt | National Citizens Ar
Witness Testimony Keywords from Transcript Licensed Practical Nurse, Nova Scotia Health Authority, Section 32 Order, State of Emergency, Mandatory Vaccination Policy, Religious Exemption Denial, Immunization Disclosure Form, Unpaid Administrative Leave, Workplace Division, Mental Health Crisis, Psychiatric Leave, Panic Attacks, CUPE Grievance Process, Arbitration Reference (Yvonne Mackey), Human Rights Commission Complaint, Conditional Acceptance Letter, Notice of Liability, Community Conversation Event, Definition of Fully Vaccinated Included in the Report: Ms. Janessa Blauvelt LPN Licensed Practical Nurse (LPN) Both (Professional and Personal Experience) Witness ID: NCI-W-032 Hearing Truro Nova Scotia Date: March 18, 2023 Report Inquiry into the Appropriateness and Efficacy of the COVID-19 Response in Canada; November 2023 Main Topic Healthcare Worker Vaccine Mandate, Religious Exemption Denial, and Mental Health Impact One Line Summary Licensed practical nurse Janessa Blauvelt testified that Nova Scotiaâs mandatory COVID vaccination policy led to denial of her religious exemption, psychiatric leave, and ongoing inability to work in her profession. Synopsis Janessa Blauvelt testified that she is a licensed practical nurse who worked as a float nurse at Yarmouth Regional Hospital under the Nova Scotia Health Authority. She described being removed from clinical training in March 2020 due to emergency measures and graduating later that year. She began full-time nursing work in December 2020 and testified that through 2020 and summer 2021 she did not observe COVID patients at her hospital, though a COVID ward was prepared. In October 2021, she received formal notice that COVID-19 mRNA vaccination would be mandatory to maintain employment. She testified that workplace division increased and that she experienced significant psychological distress upon learning she would lose her job if she did not comply. She sought crisis mental health support and was placed on medical leave by a psychiatrist due to stress, anxiety, depression, and panic attacks related to the mandate. She submitted religious exemption documentation, including a sworn affidavit and pastoral support letter, but received denial without stated reasons. Blauvelt testified that she filed a grievance through CUPE, contacted the Nova Scotia Human Rights Commission, and wrote to multiple elected officials, but received no substantive relief. She also submitted a conditional acceptance letter requesting employer liability for potential vaccine injury and participated in a notice of liability process with other employees. Her grievance did not proceed to arbitration, and she remains unable to work in her profession in Nova Scotia due to the ongoing vaccination requirement under the Section 32 public health order. đ How to Search the Transcript Click the âRead Transcriptâ button to open the witness testimony in your browser. Once the transcript PDF is open, you can search for any word or phrase within the document using your browserâs search feature: Windows: Press Ctrl + F Mac: Press Command (â) + F A small search box will appear. Type the word or phrase you are looking for, and the browser will highlight every occurrence within the transcript. This makes it easy to quickly locate specific topics, names, or statements within the testimony.
- Research Tools Hub | National Citizens Ar
Here you will find all of the tools required to seach the entire National Citizens Archive. Preserving The National Citizens Inquiry The National Citizens Archive (NCA) is a digital repository preserving sworn testimony, key reports, from the National citizens Inquiry into the Government's response to the COVID-19 Pandemic. The National citizens Archive preserves sworn testimony of witnesses, video recordings of the testimonies, full testimony transcripts, hearing exhibits, commissioner reports, and other documentary and video evidence for future generations of Canadians, and to support research into the COVID-19 era in Canada. Search the National Citizens Archive The National Citizens Archive contains testimony from 412 witnesses, 40 days of hearings, and thousands of pages of transcripts and reports. Explore the archive using the tools below.
- McGrath | National Citizens Ar
Witness Testimony Keywords from Transcript Nova Scotia Liquor Corporation (NSLC), Provincial Crown Corporation, Retail Management, Vaccine Mandate, Unpaid Leave, Termination Deemed Resignation, Vaccination Declaration Form, Medical Information Disclosure, Service Canada EI Denial, Misconduct Classification, Union Representation (NSGEU), Grievance Withdrawal, Occupational Health Minutes, Workplace Culture Shift, Premier Tim Houston Correspondence, Provincial Policy Extension, Seven-Week Mandate Extension Included in the Report: Ms. Sabrina McGrath Retail Store Manager Personal Experience Witness ID: NCI-W-022 Hearing Truro Nova Scotia Date: March 17, 2023 Report Inquiry into the Appropriateness and Efficacy of the COVID-19 Response in Canada; November 2023 Main Topic Provincial Crown Corporation Vaccine Mandate and Employment Termination One Line Summary NSLC store manager Sabrina McGrath testified that she was placed on unpaid leave and later deemed resigned after declining vaccination, and that her EI claim was denied as âmisconduct.â Synopsis Sabrina McGrath, a store manager with the Nova Scotia Liquor Corporation (NSLC), testified that she had received a top-performing store award and a model performance appraisal in 2021 prior to the implementation of a vaccine mandate. She stated that NSLC introduced masking, plexiglass barriers, distancing measures, and ultimately a vaccination mandate, which was implemented for existing employees on January 15, 2022. McGrath testified that she declined vaccination and was placed on unpaid leave. She further stated that when provincial mandates were lifted, NSLC extended its vaccination-related requirements for an additional seven weeks. Although employees were later permitted to return unvaccinated, they were required to complete a vaccination declaration form disclosing their status. McGrath testified that she declined to complete the form due to concerns about disclosure of medical information and was deemed to have resigned from her position in June 2022. McGrath testified that she applied for Employment Insurance benefits but was denied on the basis of âmisconduct,â which Service Canada attributed to failure to comply with the vaccine mandate, despite her Record of Employment listing unpaid leave rather than misconduct. She stated that her union declined to grieve the mandate itself, citing case law, and only pursued a limited grievance related to the seven-week extension period, which was later withdrawn in her case because she was no longer employed. She testified that she wrote to Premier Tim Houston and senior NSLC leadership expressing opposition to mandates but received no substantive response. đ How to Search the Transcript Click the âRead Transcriptâ button to open the witness testimony in your browser. Once the transcript PDF is open, you can search for any word or phrase within the document using your browserâs search feature: Windows: Press Ctrl + F Mac: Press Command (â) + F A small search box will appear. Type the word or phrase you are looking for, and the browser will highlight every occurrence within the transcript. This makes it easy to quickly locate specific topics, names, or statements within the testimony.
- McLeod | National Citizens Ar
Witness Testimony Keywords from Transcript Pfizer Phase III trial, randomized controlled trial critique, relative versus absolute risk, natural immunity comparison, surrogate endpoint validity, transmission not tested, crossover unblinding issue, severe adverse events increase, all-cause mortality concern, reactogenicity reporting, gene therapy classification, regulatory capture allegation, conflict of interest analysis, adaptive trial design, safety testing limitations Included in the Report: Ms. Deanna McLeod Medical Research Analyst Expert Witness ID: NCI-W-048 Hearing Vancouver British Columbia Date: May 2, 2023 Report Inquiry into the Appropriateness and Efficacy of the COVID-19 Response in Canada; November 2023 Main Topic Critical analysis of Pfizerâs Phase III mRNA COVID-19 vaccine trial design, data reporting practices, safety outcomes, and regulatory oversight. One Line Summary Medical research analyst argues Pfizerâs Phase III trial overstated efficacy, minimized safety signals, and was influenced by financial and regulatory conflicts. Synopsis Deanna McLeod, founder of a medical research analysis firm, presented a detailed critique of Pfizerâs Phase III mRNA COVID-19 vaccine trial, focusing on trial design, data interpretation, and regulatory context. She testified that the trial was industry-sponsored and conducted among healthy participants rather than high-risk populations, measured outcomes at a single early time point, and did not evaluate transmission. She argued that the trial compared vaccination to placebo rather than to natural immunity, despite prior evidence suggesting comparable immune responses, and relied on surrogate markers without validated correlates of protection. McLeod further testified that efficacy was presented using relative risk reductions rather than absolute risk reductions, which she stated substantially reduced the apparent benefit. She described cohort pooling and early unblinding with crossover of placebo recipients as design choices that limited long-term safety evaluation. She highlighted reported increases in severe adverse events in the vaccine arm compared to placebo, differences in serious adverse events, and a numerical imbalance in deaths, including cardiovascular deaths, which she characterized as safety signals warranting further investigation. She also raised concerns about abbreviated safety testing for a novel gene-based platform, including the absence of standard preclinical evaluations for carcinogenicity, reproductive toxicity, and long-term effects. McLeod described the broader regulatory environment as influenced by global funding networks and industry partnerships, asserting that regulatory authorities failed to adequately scrutinize the data. She concluded that, in her opinion, the trial did not demonstrate sufficient efficacy relative to risk and did not meet standards necessary to justify mass vaccination policies. đ How to Search the Transcript Click the âRead Transcriptâ button to open the witness testimony in your browser. Once the transcript PDF is open, you can search for any word or phrase within the document using your browserâs search feature: Windows: Press Ctrl + F Mac: Press Command (â) + F A small search box will appear. Type the word or phrase you are looking for, and the browser will highlight every occurrence within the transcript. This makes it easy to quickly locate specific topics, names, or statements within the testimony.
- Search Ideas | National Citizens Ar
Use the Search Ideas tool to explore 16 subject categories and nearly 6,200 suggested keywords, helping you find relevant testimony, reports, and topics in the National Citizens Archive. Search Ideas Browse suggested topics and keywords from the National Citizens Archive. The National Citizens Archive contains hundreds of witness testimonies, hearing materials, and commissioner report content. If you are not sure where to begin, use the search ideas below to explore common topics, witness themes, professions, and public policy issues. Search Categories Category: Business & Economic Impacts Description: Search topics related to business closures, financial hardship, economic disruption, lost income, and the broader financial effects of pandemic policies. Category: Children, Schools & Families Description: Search topics related to children, families, school closures, education, parental concerns, child development, and the effects of mandates on family life. Category: Employment, Mandates & Job Loss Description: Search topics related to workplace mandates, job loss, unpaid leave, professional discipline, employment rights, and vaccine-related work requirements. Category: Government Policy & Public Health Orders Description: Search topics related to public health orders, government decision-making, emergency measures, enforcement policies, and official pandemic response actions. Category: Health & Medical Issues Description: Search topics related to medical care, informed consent, patient treatment, access to healthcare, medical decisions, and broader health-related concerns. Category: Healthcare Workers & Professional Ethics Description: Search topics related to doctors, nurses, healthcare professionals, professional discipline, medical ethics, conscience rights, and standards of care. Category: Lockdowns & Restrictions Description: Search topics related to lockdowns, gathering limits, travel restrictions, quarantine rules, isolation requirements, and restrictions on daily life. Category: Media, Censorship & Public Messaging Description: Search topics related to media coverage, public messaging, censorship, misinformation claims, social media restrictions, and control of public debate. Category: Mental Health & Social Harm Description: Search topics related to anxiety, depression, isolation, grief, stress, social division, loneliness, and the emotional effects of pandemic policies. Category: Other / Cross-Topic Search Terms Description: Search broader or overlapping terms that may connect multiple areas of testimony, reports, witnesses, and public policy concerns. Category: Religious & Community Impacts Description: Search topics related to churches, faith communities, worship restrictions, community gatherings, religious freedom, and the effects on community life. Category: Rights, Freedoms & Legal Issues Description: Search topics related to Charter rights, civil liberties, legal challenges, freedom of conscience, mobility rights, privacy, and constitutional concerns. Category: Science, Data & Statistics Description: Search topics related to scientific evidence, public health data, modelling, statistics, risk analysis, testing, reporting, and expert interpretation. Category: Seniors & Long-Term Care Description: Search topics related to seniors, care homes, isolation, visitation restrictions, long-term care policies, family separation, and elder care concerns. Category: Vaccine Injuries & Adverse Events Description: Search topics related to vaccine injuries, adverse events, medical reactions, reporting systems, informed consent, and personal injury testimony. Category: Witness Types & Profession Description: Search by witness role, profession, background, area of expertise, or type of testimony, including expert and personal experience witnesses.









