top of page
Divider Lines_edited_edited.png

🔍 How to Use the Archive Search

 

Use the search bar below to explore the National Citizens Archive. This is a powerful tool designed to help you quickly locate specific information across reports, transcripts, videos, and exhibits.

​

Tips for Best Results:

  • Search by keywords or phrases
    Enter a single word (e.g., vaccine, mandates, Charter) or a phrase (e.g., informed consent, adverse events).

  • Use specific terms
    The more precise your search, the more relevant your results will be. Try names, topics, or key terms from testimony.

  • Try different variations
    If you don’t find what you’re looking for, try synonyms or alternate wording.

  • Results include multiple content types
    Your search may return matches from reports, witness transcripts, video pages, and other archive materials.

  • Results are ranked by relevance
    The most relevant matches will appear first.

 

⏳ Please Be Patient

This archive contains a very large volume of content, including thousands of pages of testimony and documentation.

  • Initial results may take a few moments to load

  • If results appear incomplete, allow additional time for the search to fully populate

  • You can refine your search at any time to narrow results

 

💡 Helpful Tip

 

Once you open a document (such as a transcript or report), you can use your browser’s Find function (Ctrl+F or Cmd+F) to quickly locate specific words within that page.

Divider Lines_edited_edited.png
Not sureWhat To Search For Button_edited.png

Search this site

837 results found with an empty search

  • Dowd | National Citizens Ar

    Witness Testimony Keywords from Transcript group life insurance data, excess mortality 2021, Society of Actuaries report, working-age deaths rise, BLS disability increase, employed disability surge, vaccine rollout timeline, actuarial anomaly claim, all-cause mortality review, financial risk modeling, insurance industry impact, corporate earnings warnings, pandemic data correlation, public health policy critique, economic consequences Included in the Report: Mr. Edward Dowd Financial Analyst Expert Witness ID: NCI-W-205 Hearing Vancouver British Columbia Date: May 3, 2023 Report Inquiry into the Appropriateness and Efficacy of the COVID-19 Response in Canada; November 2023 Main Topic Analysis of excess mortality, disability trends, and insurance industry data following COVID-19 vaccine rollout. One Line Summary Financial analyst presents insurance and labor data indicating excess mortality and rising disability among working-age populations following vaccine rollout. Synopsis Edward Dowd, a former Wall Street portfolio manager and founding partner of Phinance Technologies, testified regarding statistical analysis of mortality and disability data in the United States following the rollout of COVID-19 vaccines. He stated that he reviewed publicly available group life insurance data from the Society of Actuaries and observed elevated excess mortality among working-age individuals in 2021 compared to historical baselines. He testified that these increases were significant relative to normal actuarial expectations. Dowd further described analysis of U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics disability data, which he stated showed an increase in reported disabilities among employed individuals beginning in 2021. He presented correlations between vaccine rollout timelines and observed increases in disability and excess mortality, while acknowledging that correlation alone does not establish causation. He characterized the patterns as statistically unusual and warranting further investigation. He also testified regarding broader financial and economic implications, including impacts on insurance industry performance, corporate risk exposure, and workforce participation. Dowd stated that actuarial anomalies should prompt transparent review by regulatory and public health authorities and called for independent examination of all-cause mortality and disability trends to determine underlying causes. 🔎 How to Search the Transcript Click the “Read Transcript” button to open the witness testimony in your browser. Once the transcript PDF is open, you can search for any word or phrase within the document using your browser’s search feature: Windows: Press Ctrl + F Mac: Press Command (⌘) + F A small search box will appear. Type the word or phrase you are looking for, and the browser will highlight every occurrence within the transcript. This makes it easy to quickly locate specific topics, names, or statements within the testimony.

  • Havas | National Citizens Ar

    Detailed Commissioner Report Info Referenced in the Report National Citizens Inquiry (NCI) Investigation: Are Children Safe in Canada April 30, 2025 Report ID: Publication Date No. Of Pages: NCI-R-04 April 30, 2024 1267 April 22, 2023 Report National Citizens Inquiry (NCI) Investigation: Are Children Safe in Canada April 30, 2025 Main Topic Purpose and Need for the NCI The National Citizens Inquiry (NCI) was established in response to growing public concerns over the Canadian government’s handling of the COVID-19 event. As the COVID-19 emergency measures unfolded, questions arose regarding the appropriateness and efficacy of the measures implemented, including lockdowns, mandates, and the deployment of COVID-19 “vaccines.” These concerns fuelled the need for a thorough examination of the impact these policies had on health, the economy, on society and civil liberties. The NCI, conceived as an independent and citizen led initiative, sought to comprehensively investigate these issues. Its primary purpose was to provide a platform for individuals and experts to share their experiences, insights, and evidence, in order to uncover the truth, hold authorities accountable, and improve future public health responses. On November 28, 2023, the NCI Commissioners released their comprehensive final report, titled Inquiry into the Appropriateness and Efficacy of the COVID-19 Response in Canada . A year later, on November 28, 2024, a supplemental report was issued as part of the NCI’s ongoing efforts to address new and emerging concerns related to the COVID-19 investigation. Having completed its original mandate of investigating the appropriateness and efficacy of the COVID-19 measures, the NCI expanded its focus. After consulting with a broad range of Canadians, the NCI recognized a significant public concern regarding the current state of children's safety in Canada. Consequently, the NCI undertook a new investigation specifically aimed at evaluating and safeguarding the well-being of children across the country. One Line Summary Heading 2 Synopsis Heading 2

  • Flippin | National Citizens Ar

    Detailed Commissioner Report Info Referenced in the Report National Citizens Inquiry (NCI) Investigation: Are Children Safe in Canada April 30, 2025 Report ID: Publication Date No. Of Pages: NCI-R-04 April 30, 2024 1267 April 21, 2023 Report National Citizens Inquiry (NCI) Investigation: Are Children Safe in Canada April 30, 2025 Main Topic Purpose and Need for the NCI The National Citizens Inquiry (NCI) was established in response to growing public concerns over the Canadian government’s handling of the COVID-19 event. As the COVID-19 emergency measures unfolded, questions arose regarding the appropriateness and efficacy of the measures implemented, including lockdowns, mandates, and the deployment of COVID-19 “vaccines.” These concerns fuelled the need for a thorough examination of the impact these policies had on health, the economy, on society and civil liberties. The NCI, conceived as an independent and citizen led initiative, sought to comprehensively investigate these issues. Its primary purpose was to provide a platform for individuals and experts to share their experiences, insights, and evidence, in order to uncover the truth, hold authorities accountable, and improve future public health responses. On November 28, 2023, the NCI Commissioners released their comprehensive final report, titled Inquiry into the Appropriateness and Efficacy of the COVID-19 Response in Canada . A year later, on November 28, 2024, a supplemental report was issued as part of the NCI’s ongoing efforts to address new and emerging concerns related to the COVID-19 investigation. Having completed its original mandate of investigating the appropriateness and efficacy of the COVID-19 measures, the NCI expanded its focus. After consulting with a broad range of Canadians, the NCI recognized a significant public concern regarding the current state of children's safety in Canada. Consequently, the NCI undertook a new investigation specifically aimed at evaluating and safeguarding the well-being of children across the country. One Line Summary Heading 2 Synopsis Heading 2

  • NCI-R-03-Item-1-1 | National Citizens Ar

    1.1 Overview of the National Citizens Inquiry 1. Overview of the National Citizens Inquiry (NCI) 1.1 Purpose and Need for the NCI The NCI was established in response to growing public concern over the Canadian government’s handling of the COVID-19 pandemic. As the pandemic unfolded, numerous questions arose regarding the appropriateness and efficacy of the measures implemented, including lockdowns, mandates, and the deployment of COVID-19 “vaccines.“ There was a pressing need to examine these measures’ impact on health, economy, and civil liberties. The NCI was conceived as an independent, citizen-led initiative to investigate these issues comprehensively. Its primary purpose was to provide a platform for individuals affected by the pandemic policies to share their experiences, insights, and evidence. The aim was to uncover the truth, hold authorities accountable, and ensure that future public health responses are better informed and more balanced. Structure and Methodology The NCI originally conducted hearings across eight Canadian cities from March to May 2023, gathering testimonies from a diverse array of witnesses, including medical professionals, economists, legal experts, and everyday citizens. These original hearings were meticulously recorded, transcribed, and analyzed to form the basis of the NCI’s findings. The November 28, 2023 Final Report The final report of the NCI, published on November 28, 2023, represents a comprehensive and detailed examination of Canada’s COVID-19 response. It is divided into three volumes: Volume 1: Executive Summary Volume 2: Analysis Volume 3: Transcripts Key Findings The 2023 Report identified several critical areas of concern: Health Impacts: The 2023 Report highlighted significant adverse effects associated with COVID-19 vaccines, including emerging data on long-term health risks. Economic Consequences: The economic fallout of lockdowns and other restrictive measures was thoroughly examined, revealing substantial negative impacts on businesses and livelihoods. Civil Liberties: The 2023 Report detailed instances where pandemic measures infringed upon individual rights and freedoms, raising questions about the balance between public health and civil liberties. Government Accountability: The 2023 Report underscored the lack of transparency and accountability in the decision-making processes of health authorities and the government. The Need for the NCI The NCI was crucial for several reasons: Independent Scrutiny: In the absence of government-initiated investigations, the NCI provided an independent and unbiased examination of the pandemic response. Public Participation: It offered a platform for citizens to voice their experiences and concerns, ensuring that the inquiry reflected a broad spectrum of perspectives. Evidence-Based Recommendations: The NCI aimed to produce actionable recommendations based on solid evidence to guide future public health policies. Purpose and Aim of the NCI The overarching aim of the NCI was to foster a more transparent, accountable, and effective public health response in the future. Specific objectives included: Uncovering the Truth: To investigate and document the real impacts of the COVID-19 measures on health, economy, and society. Promoting Accountability: To hold those in power accountable for their decisions and actions during the pandemic. Informing Policy: To provide evidence-based recommendations that would inform better policy decisions in future public health crises. Engaging the Public: To engage citizens in a meaningful dialogue about their rights, freedoms, and the role of government in managing public health. The NCI’s work culminated in the November 28, 2023 Report, which serves as a vital document for understanding the multifaceted impacts of the COVID-19 response and the urgent need for reform in how such crises are managed. The subsequent lack of action by the government and the emergence of new, critical information necessitated further hearings, emphasizing the ongoing importance of the NCI’s mission. Report Content Reader Page 📄 Note to Readers The content presented on this page has been adapted for online viewing and navigation. Due to formatting limitations within the web display system, certain elements—such as layout, spacing, and visual structure—may differ slightly from the original report. For the complete and fully formatted version, we encourage you to download the official PDF available on the Report Information page. The PDF reflects the report exactly as it was originally written and published.

  • NCI-R-04-Item-5-1-1 | National Citizens Ar

    5.1.1 Curriculum Content and Ideological Influence 5.1 Education and School Environment 5.1.1 Curriculum Content and Ideological Influence Recommendations Increase Parental Involvement and Transparency: Establish policies that mandate active consultation with parents on curriculum changes, especially those involving sensitive or ideological content. Form parent advisory committees to review proposed curriculum updates and provide feedback before implementation. 2. Develop Age-Appropriate Content Guidelines: Collaborate with educational psychologists and child development experts to create content guidelines that align with students' cognitive and emotional readiness. Introduce sensitive topics gradually, ensuring they are framed in an age-appropriate and supportive manner, as long as these topics are approved by the specific community being served by that school. 3. Ensure Diverse and Balanced Curriculum Content: Conduct regular reviews of curriculum materials to identify and address potential ideological bias. Prioritize critical thinking by exposing students to diverse perspectives on social, political, and cultural issues. 4. Limit Transnational Influence and Prioritize Local Needs: Require transparency in adopting international frameworks, ensuring they are tailored to reflect Canadian values and community priorities. Include local educators, parents, and community leaders in decision-making processes for curriculum development. 5. Provide Training for Educators on Ideological Neutrality: Offer professional development programs to help teachers present sensitive content in a neutral and balanced manner. Train educators to foster respectful classroom discussions that accommodate diverse perspectives. 6. Implement Regular Curriculum Audits: Establish periodic audits of educational materials to monitor for unintentional ideological bias. Involve feedback from students, parents, and educators in evaluating curriculum effectiveness and fairness. Audit classrooms to identify and eliminate any materials that are not in keeping with the local community standards. 7. Enhance Safeguards for Explicit Content: Introduce stricter guidelines for the inclusion of explicit materials, requiring thorough reviews by parents and community representatives before approval. By implementing these measures, Canadian schools can create a balanced and inclusive learning environment that respects students' developmental needs, fosters critical thinking, and strengthens collaboration between families and educators. Report Content Reader Page 📄 Note to Readers The content presented on this page has been adapted for online viewing and navigation. Due to formatting limitations within the web display system, certain elements—such as layout, spacing, and visual structure—may differ slightly from the original report. For the complete and fully formatted version, we encourage you to download the official PDF available on the Report Information page. The PDF reflects the report exactly as it was originally written and published.

  • Galvin | National Citizens Ar

    Witness Testimony Keywords from Transcript student suicide January 2022, University of Guelph lockdown, residence closure decision, virtual learning isolation, high school graduation cancellation, hospital visitation denial, suicide attempt November 2020, campus COVID fines, vaccine mandate campus, snow day virtual closure, parental exclusion hospital, youth mental health decline, media fear messaging critique, student bill of rights proposal, unelected health unit authority Included in the Report: Ms. Elizabeth Galvin Parent and Advocate Personal Experience Witness ID: NCI-W-044 Hearing Toronto Ontario Date: March 30, 2023 Report Inquiry into the Appropriateness and Efficacy of the COVID-19 Response in Canada; November 2023 Main Topic Testimony describing her daughter’s suicide and the mental health impact of prolonged school closures, isolation, and campus restrictions. One Line Summary Elizabeth Galvin testified that prolonged school closures, campus isolation, and repeated lockdowns severely affected her daughter’s mental health, culminating in her suicide in January 2022. Synopsis Elizabeth Galvin testified that her 20-year-old daughter, Danielle, died by suicide in January 2022 following nearly two years of disrupted education, isolation, and repeated lockdowns. She described how Danielle’s final year of high school in 2020 was abruptly ended with virtual learning, cancelled graduation events, and limited employment opportunities. Danielle chose the University of Guelph partly because it initially indicated residences would be open, but shortly after acceptance the university reversed that decision, resulting in a restricted and largely virtual first-year experience. Galvin testified that residence life was highly limited, with minimal social interaction, closed facilities, and predominantly self-directed online instruction. In November 2020, Danielle attempted suicide and was hospitalized; Galvin stated she was denied entry to the hospital due to COVID restrictions and was unable to advocate for her daughter’s care. Danielle was released within 72 hours despite being assessed as a danger to herself. Galvin described ongoing isolation, campus enforcement actions including fines for small gatherings, difficulty forming peer connections, and persistent uncertainty about further closures. In January 2022, after another government lockdown and campus shutdown despite student vaccination requirements, Danielle was again learning virtually when she died by suicide. Galvin cited data she had reviewed indicating increases in eating disorders, suicidal ideation, opioid deaths, and parental depression during the pandemic. She concluded that prolonged school closures and lockdown policies harmed youth mental health and called for reforms including hospital visitation protections, limits on unelected public health authority, education service guarantees for students, and protection against extended school shutdowns for healthy young people. 🔎 How to Search the Transcript Click the “Read Transcript” button to open the witness testimony in your browser. Once the transcript PDF is open, you can search for any word or phrase within the document using your browser’s search feature: Windows: Press Ctrl + F Mac: Press Command (⌘) + F A small search box will appear. Type the word or phrase you are looking for, and the browser will highlight every occurrence within the transcript. This makes it easy to quickly locate specific topics, names, or statements within the testimony.

  • Vossen | National Citizens Ar

    Witness Testimony Keywords from Transcript Red River College Mandate, Proof of Vaccination Requirement, Online Registration Blocked, Exemption Denials Reported, Students Against Mandates, Instagram Advocacy Platform, Canada-Wide Student Network, Vaccine Injury Reports, Professor Coercion Claim, Mental Health Crisis Allegation, Social Ostracization, Employment Interview Discrimination, Media Smear Campaign, Death Threats, Home Break-In Incident Included in the Report: Ms. Leigh Vossen Student and Non-Profit Founder Personal Experience Witness ID: NCI-W-110 Hearing Winnipeg Manitoba Date: April 15, 2023 Report Inquiry into the Appropriateness and Efficacy of the COVID-19 Response in Canada; November 2023 Main Topic Testimony describing university vaccine mandate enforcement that prevented completion of her final semester, creation of Students Against Mandates, widespread reports of student coercion and injury, social ostracization, employment discrimination, and personal safety threats. One Line Summary Leigh Vossen testified that Red River College’s vaccine mandate blocked her final semester, leading her to co-found Students Against Mandates and exposing her to widespread student distress reports, public attacks, and personal safety threats. Synopsis Leigh Vossen testified that she enrolled in Business Administration at Red River College in January 2021 after leaving her job as a graphic designer. She completed three terms online without issue. Prior to her fourth and final semester, the college moved her program to in-person instruction and required proof of vaccination to attend campus. As an unvaccinated student, she requested alternative online access but testified that her course registration portal was temporarily frozen and available online sections filled before she could register. She chose not to complete the final semester, stating she could not support what she viewed as discriminatory policies. In response to what she described as administrative refusal to discuss data supporting mandates, she created the Instagram account “Students Against Mandates,” which evolved into a Canada-wide non-profit organization. She testified to receiving hundreds of detailed messages from students, professors, administrators, and others reporting feelings of isolation, coercion, denied exemptions, job loss, and vaccine injuries. She described hosting in-person meetups and community gatherings to support affected students and stated that some contacts reported mental health deterioration and rising suicide concerns at post-secondary institutions. Vossen further testified that her activism led to significant backlash, including media articles labeling her an extremist, loss of friendships, employment discrimination during job interviews, online harassment, death threats, and a break-in at her residence shortly after her address was publicly shared. Despite these experiences, she stated that founding Students Against Mandates provided community and purpose during the pandemic. She concluded that mandates represented unjust segregation and coercion, and that institutions failed to provide data justifying their policies. 🔎 How to Search the Transcript Click the “Read Transcript” button to open the witness testimony in your browser. Once the transcript PDF is open, you can search for any word or phrase within the document using your browser’s search feature: Windows: Press Ctrl + F Mac: Press Command (⌘) + F A small search box will appear. Type the word or phrase you are looking for, and the browser will highlight every occurrence within the transcript. This makes it easy to quickly locate specific topics, names, or statements within the testimony.

  • Bourgault | National Citizens Ar

    Witness Testimony Keywords from Transcript early treatment advocacy, hydroxychloroquine support, ivermectin support, quercetin zinc protocol, vitamin D promotion, mask safety testing claim, carbon dioxide levels, Occupational Health regulations, pediatric vaccine opposition, myocarditis allegation, Freedom Convoy involvement, Canadians for Truth organization, media censorship allegations, criminal negligence claims, vaccine mandate refusal Included in the Report: Mr. Joseph Bourgault Business Executive Both (Expert and Personal Experience) Witness ID: NCI-W-126 Hearing Saskatoon Saskatchewan Date: April 20, 2023 Report Inquiry into the Appropriateness and Efficacy of the COVID-19 Response in Canada; November 2023 Main Topic Advocacy for early COVID-19 therapeutics, opposition to mask mandates and pediatric vaccination, and allegations of institutional suppression and negligence. One Line Summary A Saskatchewan manufacturing executive alleges suppression of early COVID-19 treatments, unsafe mask mandates, and wrongful promotion of pediatric mRNA vaccination. Synopsis Joseph Bourgault, president and CEO of F.P. Bourgault Tillage Tools and co-founder of Canadians for Truth, Freedom and Justice, testified regarding his opposition to COVID-19 public health measures. He described assisting organizers during the Ottawa Freedom Convoy and characterized the protest as peaceful and lawful. Drawing on his background in business leadership and personal health research, he stated that early outpatient treatments such as hydroxychloroquine, ivermectin, quercetin with zinc, and vitamin D were effective and were intentionally suppressed, resulting in preventable deaths. He alleged that governments, regulatory bodies, and media organizations participated in coordinated suppression of therapeutic options. Bourgault testified that his organization published protocols and reports advocating early treatment and opposing pediatric mRNA vaccination. He cited federal statistics indicating low pediatric mortality from COVID-19 and argued that the risks of vaccination outweighed the benefits for children. He asserted that provincial officials were warned through a formal risk analysis submission. He further alleged that adverse event reporting systems and myocarditis data indicated significant vaccine-related harm, and characterized the rollout as negligent. In addition, Bourgault described conducting workplace carbon dioxide and oxygen measurements behind various masks, asserting that mask use resulted in elevated carbon dioxide levels and reduced oxygen levels inconsistent with occupational health standards. He stated that his company did not impose vaccine mandates and reported no COVID-related deaths among employees. He concluded by calling for political accountability, institutional reform, and the election of leaders committed to truth, individual liberty, and informed consent principles. 🔎 How to Search the Transcript Click the “Read Transcript” button to open the witness testimony in your browser. Once the transcript PDF is open, you can search for any word or phrase within the document using your browser’s search feature: Windows: Press Ctrl + F Mac: Press Command (⌘) + F A small search box will appear. Type the word or phrase you are looking for, and the browser will highlight every occurrence within the transcript. This makes it easy to quickly locate specific topics, names, or statements within the testimony.

  • Setka | National Citizens Ar

    Witness Testimony Keywords from Transcript Family Estrangement, Vaccine Status Division, Social Ostracization, Church Vaccine Passport, Christmas Service Segregation, Undeclared Section Isolation, Religious Freedom Concern, Business Travel Ban, Flight Mandate Restriction, Cross-Country Driving Requirement, Networking Exclusion, Living Alone Lockdown, Mental Health Decline, Students Against Mandates Support, Bodily Autonomy Belief Included in the Report: Mr. Steven Setka Freight Broker Personal Experience Witness ID: NCI-W-107 Hearing Winnipeg Manitoba Date: April 15, 2023 Report Inquiry into the Appropriateness and Efficacy of the COVID-19 Response in Canada; November 2023 Main Topic Testimony describing family estrangement, church segregation through vaccine passport enforcement, travel restrictions impacting business operations, and significant mental health effects resulting from vaccine mandates and lockdown policies. One Line Summary Freight broker Steven Setka testified that vaccine mandates fractured family relationships, segregated him at church, restricted business travel, and caused prolonged mental health strain during lockdowns. Synopsis Steven Setka testified that prior to the pandemic he was part of a close-knit extended family in Winnipeg that gathered regularly for holidays, sporting activities, and social events. As the pandemic progressed and he chose not to be vaccinated, divisions emerged within his extended family. He stated that some households no longer invited him to gatherings, and that vaccinated members were welcomed while unvaccinated members were excluded. He described long-term damage to family relationships and feelings of ostracization tied to vaccination status and differing views on government restrictions. Setka also described his experience at Oasis Church during the implementation of vaccine passport policies. He met with church leadership to express concern about separating congregants by vaccination status. At a Christmas Eve service, he attended the designated section for undeclared individuals and testified that he was the only person seated in that segregated area while approximately 1,000 attended the main service. He subsequently left the church and joined another congregation that he said emphasized personal autonomy and Charter freedoms. Professionally, Setka testified that travel bans and flight mandates prevented him from attending work conventions in Canada and the United States, requiring him and his business partner to drive long distances to fulfill obligations. He stated that prolonged isolation, living alone during portions of lockdown, and exclusion from social and professional networks led to significant feelings of sadness, anger, anxiety, and depression. He expressed the view that pandemic policy should have emphasized individual autonomy, personal responsibility, and risk choice rather than enforced restrictions. 🔎 How to Search the Transcript Click the “Read Transcript” button to open the witness testimony in your browser. Once the transcript PDF is open, you can search for any word or phrase within the document using your browser’s search feature: Windows: Press Ctrl + F Mac: Press Command (⌘) + F A small search box will appear. Type the word or phrase you are looking for, and the browser will highlight every occurrence within the transcript. This makes it easy to quickly locate specific topics, names, or statements within the testimony.

  • Shoemaker | National Citizens Ar

    Detailed Commissioner Report Info Referenced in the Report National Citizens Inquiry (NCI) Investigation: Are Children Safe in Canada April 30, 2025 Report ID: Publication Date No. Of Pages: NCI-R-04 April 30, 2024 1267 May 19, 2023 Report National Citizens Inquiry (NCI) Investigation: Are Children Safe in Canada April 30, 2025 Main Topic Purpose and Need for the NCI The National Citizens Inquiry (NCI) was established in response to growing public concerns over the Canadian government’s handling of the COVID-19 event. As the COVID-19 emergency measures unfolded, questions arose regarding the appropriateness and efficacy of the measures implemented, including lockdowns, mandates, and the deployment of COVID-19 “vaccines.” These concerns fuelled the need for a thorough examination of the impact these policies had on health, the economy, on society and civil liberties. The NCI, conceived as an independent and citizen led initiative, sought to comprehensively investigate these issues. Its primary purpose was to provide a platform for individuals and experts to share their experiences, insights, and evidence, in order to uncover the truth, hold authorities accountable, and improve future public health responses. On November 28, 2023, the NCI Commissioners released their comprehensive final report, titled Inquiry into the Appropriateness and Efficacy of the COVID-19 Response in Canada . A year later, on November 28, 2024, a supplemental report was issued as part of the NCI’s ongoing efforts to address new and emerging concerns related to the COVID-19 investigation. Having completed its original mandate of investigating the appropriateness and efficacy of the COVID-19 measures, the NCI expanded its focus. After consulting with a broad range of Canadians, the NCI recognized a significant public concern regarding the current state of children's safety in Canada. Consequently, the NCI undertook a new investigation specifically aimed at evaluating and safeguarding the well-being of children across the country. One Line Summary Heading 2 Synopsis Heading 2

  • Bahar | National Citizens Ar

    Witness Testimony Keywords from Transcript Federal Vaccine Mandate, Federal Public Service, Leave Without Pay, Remote Work Accommodation Request, Testing Alternative Offered, Union Representation Delay, Grievance Process Stalled, Collective Agreement Timelines Ignored, Lockout from System Access, Income Loss (Estimated $60,000–$70,000), Financial Hardship, Savings Depletion, Secondary Employment Contract, Vaccine Passport Travel Restriction, Inability to Fly, Interprovincial Travel by Car, Social Ostracism, Small Community Stigma, Relationship Strain, Charter Rights Concern, Consideration of Emigration Included in the Report: Mr. Joe Bahar Federal Public Servant Personal Experience Witness ID: NCI-W-025 Hearing Truro Nova Scotia Date: March 17, 2023 Report Inquiry into the Appropriateness and Efficacy of the COVID-19 Response in Canada; November 2023 Main Topic Federal Vaccine Mandate, Leave Without Pay, Union Grievance Delay, and Social Impact of Vaccine Passports One Line Summary Federal civil servant Joe Behare testified that he was placed on unpaid leave despite working remotely, lost approximately $60,000–$70,000 in income, and experienced travel restrictions and social ostracism under vaccine passport policies. Synopsis Joe Behar testified that he is a federal civil servant from Baie Verte, New Brunswick, with 20 years of service and managerial experience. He stated that during the federal vaccine mandate announcement in fall 2021, he was working remotely under a secondment agreement and was not required to attend a physical workplace. He declined vaccination and requested accommodation, offering masking and testing at his own expense. He testified that accommodation was denied and that he was placed on leave without pay effective November 17, 2021. Behar described being locked out of all government systems before the end of his final workday, including loss of access to personal contacts, leave balances, and HR documentation. He filed a grievance through his union after the union initially declined representation but later agreed to proceed on a case-by-case basis. He testified that grievance timelines outlined in the collective agreement were not respected and that more than a year later he had received no final resolution. He estimated his lost income during the leave period at approximately $60,000–$70,000 and described depleting savings before securing a lower-paying temporary contract position. He further testified that vaccine passport policies restricted his ability to fly to visit his elderly mother in Ontario or his daughter in the United States. He described social ostracism in his small community, strained family relationships, and a loss of trust in institutions. He stated that the experience left him alarmed about the state of constitutional protections and that, for the first time, he contemplated leaving Canada. 🔎 How to Search the Transcript Click the “Read Transcript” button to open the witness testimony in your browser. Once the transcript PDF is open, you can search for any word or phrase within the document using your browser’s search feature: Windows: Press Ctrl + F Mac: Press Command (⌘) + F A small search box will appear. Type the word or phrase you are looking for, and the browser will highlight every occurrence within the transcript. This makes it easy to quickly locate specific topics, names, or statements within the testimony.

  • Payne | National Citizens Ar

    Witness Testimony Keywords from Transcript relative vs absolute risk reduction, number needed to vaccinate, natural immunity superiority, antibody dependent enhancement, negative vaccine effectiveness claim, Omicron breakthrough data, pediatric myocarditis modeling, biodistribution spike protein, reverse transcription concern, VAERS adverse event comparison, masking RCT evidence absence, Alberta mandate termination, regulatory investigation complaint, batch variability allegation, informed consent failure Included in the Report: Dr. Eric Payne MD, MPH Pediatric Neurologist Both (Expert and Personal Experience) Witness ID: NCI-W-071 Hearing Toronto Ontario Date: April 1, 2023 Report Inquiry into the Appropriateness and Efficacy of the COVID-19 Response in Canada; November 2023 Main Topic Scientific critique of COVID-19 vaccine efficacy claims, safety data transparency, pediatric risk–benefit analysis, and professional repercussions for dissent. One Line Summary Pediatric neurologist Dr. Eric Payne testified that COVID-19 vaccine efficacy was misrepresented using relative risk figures, that safety and biodistribution concerns were inadequately studied, and that he faced professional consequences for raising these issues. Synopsis Dr. Eric Payne testified that shortly after relocating from the Mayo Clinic to Calgary in February 2020, he became concerned about vaccine mandates tying medical licensure and employment to COVID-19 vaccination. In September 2021 he submitted an 18-page, reference-supported letter to the College of Physicians and Surgeons of Alberta challenging the scientific and ethical basis of mandates. He argued that public messaging misrepresented efficacy by emphasizing relative risk reduction (e.g., 95%) rather than absolute risk reduction (approximately 1%), resulting in a high number needed to vaccinate to prevent a single mild case. He testified that vaccines did not prevent transmission as initially claimed and cited provincial and international data showing breakthrough infections and what he characterized as negative effectiveness during the Omicron wave. Payne further testified that risk–benefit calculations were especially problematic in children, referencing modelling data that projected minimal pediatric lives saved relative to myocarditis risk. He emphasized natural-acquired immunity studies, stating that post-infection immunity provided robust protection against severe disease. He raised concerns regarding antibody-dependent enhancement, immune imprinting, and evolutionary pressure from mass vaccination during an active pandemic. He also discussed biodistribution findings, stating that mRNA and spike protein were detected beyond the injection site, including in organs, breast milk, and cerebrospinal fluid in certain studies, and cited laboratory findings suggesting potential reverse transcription in vitro. He testified that adverse event databases (VAERS, EudraVigilance, WHO VigiAccess) showed unprecedented reporting volumes compared to historical vaccines and alleged underreporting. He further raised concerns about manufacturing batch variability and possible quality-control irregularities. Professionally, he stated he was locked out of his hospital position for non-compliance with vaccination mandates, subjected to College investigations for alleged misinformation, and later not renewed in his university role despite the policy being rescinded. He concluded by criticizing masking mandates for lack of randomized controlled trial evidence and warning of developmental harms to children from prolonged masking and school disruptions. 🔎 How to Search the Transcript Click the “Read Transcript” button to open the witness testimony in your browser. Once the transcript PDF is open, you can search for any word or phrase within the document using your browser’s search feature: Windows: Press Ctrl + F Mac: Press Command (⌘) + F A small search box will appear. Type the word or phrase you are looking for, and the browser will highlight every occurrence within the transcript. This makes it easy to quickly locate specific topics, names, or statements within the testimony.

National Citizens Archive
Witness Testimony | Commissioner Reports | Research Archive

© National Citizens Archive

Disclaimer: The National Citizens Archive is an independent archival and research initiative created to preserve, organize, and make accessible historical materials, testimony, transcripts, reports, and related public records arising from the National Citizens Inquiry process. The National Citizens Archive is not the official website of the federally incorporated National Citizens Inquiry organization, and no formal legal, corporate, or governance relationship should be inferred unless and until such a relationship is expressly agreed to in writing by the relevant parties.

Divider Lines_edited.png
bottom of page