top of page
Divider Lines_edited_edited.png

🔍 How to Use the Archive Search

 

Use the search bar below to explore the National Citizens Archive. This is a powerful tool designed to help you quickly locate specific information across reports, transcripts, videos, and exhibits.

​

Tips for Best Results:

  • Search by keywords or phrases
    Enter a single word (e.g., vaccine, mandates, Charter) or a phrase (e.g., informed consent, adverse events).

  • Use specific terms
    The more precise your search, the more relevant your results will be. Try names, topics, or key terms from testimony.

  • Try different variations
    If you don’t find what you’re looking for, try synonyms or alternate wording.

  • Results include multiple content types
    Your search may return matches from reports, witness transcripts, video pages, and other archive materials.

  • Results are ranked by relevance
    The most relevant matches will appear first.

 

⏳ Please Be Patient

This archive contains a very large volume of content, including thousands of pages of testimony and documentation.

  • Initial results may take a few moments to load

  • If results appear incomplete, allow additional time for the search to fully populate

  • You can refine your search at any time to narrow results

 

💡 Helpful Tip

 

Once you open a document (such as a transcript or report), you can use your browser’s Find function (Ctrl+F or Cmd+F) to quickly locate specific words within that page.

Divider Lines_edited_edited.png
Not sureWhat To Search For Button_edited.png

Search this site

837 results found with an empty search

  • NCI-R-02-Item-7-2-3 | National Citizens Ar

    7.2.3 Social Effects of Mandates on Canadian Institutions 7.2.3 Social Effects of Mandates on Canadian Institutions Introduction Historically, Canadians have had a high level of trust in their public institutions. Trust in public institutions is often measured through public opinion surveys which assess public confidence in various institutions, including government, parliament, the judiciary, the police, and public health agencies. While trust levels can fluctuate over time, especially in response to specific events or policies, Canada has consistently ranked relatively high, compared to many other countries, in terms of public trust in institutions. Factors contributing to this trust include Canada‘s reputation for political stability, democratic governance, and robust public services. The long-term effects of government actions during the COVID-19 pandemic has significantly reduced Canadians‘ confidence and trust in their government institutions. This erosion of trust in the fundamental institutions of Canada is prevalent not just in Canada but around the World. According to the testimony of Gail Davidson, Canada no longer enjoys the trust of its citizens or that of the citizens of much of the world. The perception of tyranny is subjective and can be influenced by a range of factors, including political biases, international relations, media narratives, and individual experiences. While opinions may differ, it is worth noting that Canada no longer enjoys a universally positive reputation for democratic governance and respect for human rights, globally. Canada‘s long standing tradition of fairness and transparency has been severely eroded, and this negative perception will affect Canadian society for generations to come. The intent of this section is to provide an overall or general commentary on the subject of institutional trust: detailed discussion and analysis of certain institutions included here are contained in other sections of this report. Testimony of Witnesses‘ Social Effects of Mandates on Canadian Institutions Many witnesses testified as to the performance of the fundamental institutions of Canadian society durning the COVID-19 pandemic. Canadian institutions that were discussed included the following: Parliament, legislatures, executive branch, Judiciary, Legal profession, Police, Healthcare, Regulatory agencies, Media, Financial institutions, Human rights organizations, Universities/public schools, Churches, and National/multinational corporations. Witness David Leis spoke at length about the absolute erosion and wanton destruction of traditional Canadians‘ confidence in their democratic institutions and how the existential survival of traditional Canadian democracy was in peril. Regina Goman spoke about her experience in communist Poland and her participation in the Solidarity movement. She told how, based on her experience in Poland, the actions of the Canadian government in restricting and cancelling basic human rights was a stark warning to Canadians that the country was slipping toward tyranny. Lt. Col. David Redman, who is an expert on emergency planning, testified that despite his expertise, he found the different levels of government would not listen to his counsel concerning the emergency response to the pandemic, and he further stated that the professionals in the emergency planning agencies were sidelined. In his opinion, the emergency response was a complete failure from the outset, and the government was hostile to any suggestions that may have improved the results. Gail Davidson, an expert in international human rights law, spoke about how, in her opinion, Canada violated the International Human Rights treaties to which Canada is a signatory and is legally obligated to uphold. Retired Judge Brian Giesbrecht testified that he felt the courts and judiciary had failed Canadians. He testified that, in his opinion, the courts were no longer accessible to Canadians and that the judiciary was avoiding their responsibility to deal with difficult issues that have arisen during the pandemic. Judges often succumbed to political pressure to follow the pandemic narrative, and Canadian citizens no longer received fair and unbiased hearings. Legal tools such as rulings of “mootness“ and “judicial notice“ were used to avoid hearing and ruling on government actions. Judges simply deferred to government regulations, robbing citizens of equal standing under the law. Lawyer Bruce Pardy spoke about how the courts have demonstrated a bias toward the government position, as opposed to testing the narrative. He also spoke about the weakness of the Charter of Rights and Freedoms . Lawyers James Kitchen, Jeffrey Rath, and Leighton Grey spoke at length about the failure of the Canadian judiciary. Several doctors—including Dr. Chris Milburn, Dr. Phillips, and others—stated that the Colleges of Physicians and Surgeons failed at protecting the public. In the opinion of the witnesses, the Colleges of Physicians and Surgeons simply enforced the government narrative and did not base their actions on an understanding of science. In addition, these regulators inserted themselves between physicians and patients as well as striking down long held principles and practices in medicine. Health Canada promoted racial division in Canada by offering early eligibility of the vaccine based on race, as opposed to identifying vulnerable people of all races, based on age and comorbidity. This practice built up a feeling of resentment within Canada. Many witnesses testified about how they were treated by the police. Tom Marazzo, Vincent Gircys , Richard Abbot, Danny Bulford, and others testified concerning the assault of citizens by police organizations during the demonstrations. In their opinion, the police were no longer acting as protectors of the public but were acting as enforcers of the government edicts. Inappropriate conduct included various breaches of many aspects of the Charter of Rights and Freedoms as well as police using excessive force when dealing with peaceful protest. Several pastors testified that the police were used to forcibly invade their churches to shut down religious services and arrest pastors. Rodney Palmer and Marianne Klowak spoke about the complete absence of any traditional journalistic standards in Canadian media. Mr. Palmer detailed bias, misleading news stories, and significant omissions of opinions that were counter to the government narrative. Several witnesses spoke about the actions of Canadian financial institutions in the freezing of bank accounts of citizens who had not been convicted of any crime. The financial institutions simply undertook to freeze bank accounts, without any push-back on the regulator, nor was there any evidence that these institutions consulted their legal counsel in any kind of an effort of protecting the rights of their depositors. Testimony was received from witnesses who refused to be coerced to take an experimental injection and, as a result, were dismissed from their jobs. Employers took unilateral actions which allegedly violated human rights. Many of these dismissed employees took their complaints to their unions and the human rights commission, where their complaints were dismissed. Neither the unions or the human rights commissions actually took any action to challenge the employers on these violations. Universities and public schools followed the government mandates without any regard for the detrimental effects that students were experiencing. The Commissioners heard testimony from retired professors, teachers, and students. In many instances, the institutions adopted policies that were more restrictive than those enacted by the government, and often they prolonged the implementation of these restrictions. According to the witnesses, students were impacted in a variety of ways that included lost educational opportunities, physical distress, and social and mental developmental damages. Further administration of many schools allowed a toxic atmosphere of hate and bullying to develop against anyone who did not comply with the narrative. Many churches failed their congregations and were in lockstep with government directives restricting their operation. This was despite the obvious contradictions in the regulations that allowed big box stores, liquor stores, and cannabis stores to remain open as essential services. After the initial pronouncement of the pandemic and lockdowns, most pastors complied and closed their churches to protect the congregations. As the mandates continued and deepened, and it became obvious that the mandates and lockdowns were wrong, many pastors reopened their churches, understanding that the church plays a vital role in the mental, social, and spiritual health of their congregations. Wesley Mack, Hon. PhD, testified on the importance of church attendance to communities of faith. Testimony was received from pastors who were fined, arrested, jailed, or forced out of their churches, including Pastor Steven Flippin, Pastor James Coates, Pastor Jason McVicar, and Tobias Tissen. Witnesses testified that national and multinational corporations, including pharmaceutical companies, allegedly took advantage of the environment of terror and panic that gripped the government and the country. Employees were terminated due to non-compliance with unilateral injection mandates. Pharmaceutical corporations took advantage of panicked and inexperienced government regulators to negotiate incredible concessions on the approval, manufacture, and distribution of an experimental gene therapy while protecting themselves from liability. Large corporations also turned over confidential client records and monitored clients on request of the government. In some instances, this was done without a court warrant and without the conscious knowledge of the clients. One example discussed was the monitoring of over 30 million Canadians, through their cell phones, by Health Canada. Conclusions Here are a few reasons why Canadians‘ trust in their institutions has been shaken: Democratic Values and Political Stability Canada was traditionally widely regarded as a stable and well-functioning democracy. It has had a long-standing tradition of upholding democratic values, including free and fair elections, the rule of law, freedom of speech, and respect for human rights. These factors contributed to Canada‘s reputation as a country with strong democratic institutions. Over the course of the pandemic, many of these democratic rights were attacked, diminished, or eliminated. The Government of Canada, along with the provincial governments, effectively suspended many of the fundamental human rights as set out in the Charter of Rights and Freedoms . They suppressed peaceful dissenting opinions; they arrested peaceful protestors; and they silenced dissent through the use of the judiciary, police, and even financial institutions.. Canadians were so accustomed to their rights that they could not bring themselves to believe what was happening before their very eyes. Many Canadians found themselves in a position where they could not obtain legal counsel, as many lawyers in Canada would not represent persons who were challenging the government lockdowns and mandates. Multiculturalism and Inclusivity Canadians are known for their commitment to multiculturalism and diversity. The Canadian government, however, had established policies and programs to promote the vilification of certain groups of Canadians by using a propagandized narrative of institutional racism. In order to “protect“ these threatened minority rights, they enacted extremely obtuse laws and regulations which are being used to stifle legitimate dissent and to force citizens to accept their extreme policies or face legal consequences. Those consequences include arrest, fines, and incarceration. This change in approach has not gone unnoticed in the international community. Strong Human Rights Record Canada has previously been recognized for its commitment to human rights, both domestically and internationally. Canada is a signatory to numerous international human rights treaties and has actively participated in global efforts to promote and protect human rights. During the pandemic, Canada enacted policies and enforced new laws which suspended human rights in the country, and many of the measures were in direct violation of the international human rights treaties to which Canada is a signatory. Gail Davidson, an expert in international law, set out the details of these gross violations, in her testimony. Canada‘s legal framework, including the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms , failed to protect the individual rights and freedoms of its citizens. Many of the most basic and fundamental rights “guaranteed“ by the Charter were simply brushed aside, under section 1 of the Charter, titled “Guarantee of Rights and Freedoms.“ By invoking this clause, and without providing clear and transparent justification of the reasons, the government was able to suspend Charter freedoms, and the judiciary did nothing to stop them. Perception of Government Response The lack of effectiveness, transparency, and communication of government responses to the pandemic influenced significant mistrust in institutions. Governments demonstrated a lack of efficient and transparent decision-making, they did not communicate clearly, and they did not implement evidence-based measures. Objectively false statements, missteps, inconsistent messaging, and delays in decision-making eroded trust. Political Polarization The pandemic became politicized in most contexts, leading to polarization and divisions along political lines. Trust in government institutions was influenced by pre-existing political beliefs, with individuals more likely to trust or distrust institutions based on their alignment with their political ideologies. Communication and Information Dissemination The ability of governments to effectively communicate accurate and timely information is crucial in building trust. The governments in Canada did not engage in open and transparent communication. Although they provided regular updates, many in the population knew that the updates were skewed and biased. In addition, the government relied on “trusted“ experts who, in many instances, were known to have received significant government funding and thus had a conflict of interest, which eroded trust in government institutions. Handling of Crisis Management The perception of how well government institutions handled the crisis—including the ability to control the spread of the virus, implement effective public health measures, and protect vulnerable populations—influenced trust. The public health officials in charge of the emergency response displayed no expertise in emergency management, and the existing emergency planning apparatus was sidelined. Elected officials who are supposed to remain in control of any crisis situation abrogated these responsibilities to non-elected, and all too often incompetent, bureaucrats with no experience in crisis management. Trust in Science and Expertise Trust in government institutions was influenced by the public‘s perception of the government‘s reliance on skewed, false, incomplete, and biased scientific evidence and expertise. Governments did not follow evidence-based decision-making and sought guidance from inept and inexperienced public health officials and even disregarding crisis plans previously developed by the same public health officials. Decisions were perceived as politically motivated or contradicting scientific consensus, further eroding the trust of Canadians. Social and Economic Impacts The social and economic impacts of COVID-19 mandates—such as business closures, job losses, and financial hardships—have influenced trust in government institutions. Individuals and communities experiencing negative consequences rightly attributed these difficulties to government decisions, which led to decreased trust. Trust in Public Health Institutions The response of public health institutions, such as the Public Health Agency of Canada and local health authorities, influenced trust in the broader government system. Trust in these institutions was crucial, as they provided guidance, expertise, and recommendations during the crisis. The directives being issued by public health were often erratic and were given in a state of panic; and many of the regulations and edicts contradicted long-held medical practice, and all too often they made no sense in a medical or scientific way. The public was never presented with an overall plan but was simply exposed to a long list of rules and regulations, without any consideration for the quickly developing situation. A dizzying array of different rules from province to province further contributed to a perception that the measures were political and not informed by good health policy. It is important to recognize the pandemic and its impact on trust in government institutions as complex and multifaceted. Trust can be influenced by a combination of factors, and individual experiences and perspectives play a role. Governments that actively address concerns, engage in transparent communication, prioritize public health, and demonstrate accountability have a better chance of rebuilding and maintaining trust in the long term. Recommendations The process of restoring trust in Canadian institutions is a very difficult and complex one. What was destroyed in a very short period of time will take a generation to restore, and only if these institutions make a concerted effort to restore that trust through their day-to-day actions. Momentary publicity campaigns and propaganda blitzes will not serve either the institutions or the people of Canada‘s best interests. If these concerns are not addressed in a forthright manner, the very existence of Canada as a free and democratic nation is at risk. We recommend the following: It is not an option to take a “business as usual“ posture and simply carry on as if nothing happened. Institutions must recognize and publicly admit their culpability in what was perpetrated on Canadians and, if appropriate, must face criminal and civil penalties for their actions. Transparency and Accountability : Information related to the institutions‘ actions during the COVID-19 pandemic must be made publicly available, creating a culture of transparency and accountability within public institutions. Ensure that decision-making processes are open and accessible to the public, and that the actions and performance of public officials are subject to scrutiny. Establish mechanisms for oversight , such as independent audits or ombudsman offices, to hold institutions accountable for their actions. Ethical Conduct : Promote and enforce high ethical standards within public institutions. Implement robust codes of conduct that govern the behaviour and decisions of public officials and employees. Provide ethics training to ensure that individuals understand their responsibilities and the expectations placed upon them. Effective Governance : Strengthen governance structures and mechanisms to ensure efficient and effective functioning of public institutions. Enhance the professionalism and expertise of public servants through training and development programs. Foster a merit-based culture that rewards competence and performance. Public Engagement : Actively engage with the public and involve stakeholders in decision-making processes. Seek public input through consultations, town hall meetings, surveys, and other participatory mechanisms. Demonstrate that public institutions are responsive to the needs and concerns of the people they serve. Communication and Information Dissemination : Establish clear and consistent communication channels to keep the public informed about the work and activities of public institutions. Provide timely and accurate information, particularly in times of crisis or controversy. Use plain language and accessible formats to ensure that information is easily understandable by all segments of society. Collaboration and Partnerships : Foster collaboration and partnerships with civil society organizations, academia, and other stakeholders. Engage in meaningful dialogue and involve external expertise in policy development and implementation. Collaborative approaches can help build trust and ensure that institutions benefit from diverse perspectives. Learn from Mistakes : Acknowledge and learn from past mistakes or failures. Publicly address any instances of wrongdoing or misconduct, and take corrective actions. Demonstrate a commitment to learning, improvement, and the prevention of similar issues in the future. Long-Term Vision and Consistency : Develop and communicate a clear long-term vision for the institution‘s role and purpose. Demonstrate consistency in actions and decision-making, avoiding unnecessary reversals or abrupt changes. Consistency helps build trust by showing that institutions are reliable, accountable, and predictable. Independent Oversight and Checks and Balances : Strengthen the role of independent oversight bodies, such as auditors general, ombudsman offices, or anti-corruption commissions. These bodies can provide an additional layer of accountability and help prevent abuses of power or corruption. Rebuilding trust in public institutions is a long-term endeavour that requires sustained commitment and effort. By implementing these strategies, institutions can work towards restoring faith in their integrity, competence, and ability to serve the public interest. Report Content Reader Page 📄 Note to Readers The content presented on this page has been adapted for online viewing and navigation. Due to formatting limitations within the web display system, certain elements—such as layout, spacing, and visual structure—may differ slightly from the original report. For the complete and fully formatted version, we encourage you to download the official PDF available on the Report Information page. The PDF reflects the report exactly as it was originally written and published.

  • Davidson | National Citizens Ar

    Detailed Commissioner Report Info Referenced in the Report National Citizens Inquiry (NCI) Investigation: Are Children Safe in Canada April 30, 2025 Report ID: Publication Date No. Of Pages: NCI-R-04 April 30, 2024 1267 March 18, 2023 Report National Citizens Inquiry (NCI) Investigation: Are Children Safe in Canada April 30, 2025 Main Topic Purpose and Need for the NCI The National Citizens Inquiry (NCI) was established in response to growing public concerns over the Canadian government’s handling of the COVID-19 event. As the COVID-19 emergency measures unfolded, questions arose regarding the appropriateness and efficacy of the measures implemented, including lockdowns, mandates, and the deployment of COVID-19 “vaccines.” These concerns fuelled the need for a thorough examination of the impact these policies had on health, the economy, on society and civil liberties. The NCI, conceived as an independent and citizen led initiative, sought to comprehensively investigate these issues. Its primary purpose was to provide a platform for individuals and experts to share their experiences, insights, and evidence, in order to uncover the truth, hold authorities accountable, and improve future public health responses. On November 28, 2023, the NCI Commissioners released their comprehensive final report, titled Inquiry into the Appropriateness and Efficacy of the COVID-19 Response in Canada . A year later, on November 28, 2024, a supplemental report was issued as part of the NCI’s ongoing efforts to address new and emerging concerns related to the COVID-19 investigation. Having completed its original mandate of investigating the appropriateness and efficacy of the COVID-19 measures, the NCI expanded its focus. After consulting with a broad range of Canadians, the NCI recognized a significant public concern regarding the current state of children's safety in Canada. Consequently, the NCI undertook a new investigation specifically aimed at evaluating and safeguarding the well-being of children across the country. One Line Summary Heading 2 Synopsis Heading 2

  • Usenko | National Citizens Ar

    Detailed Commissioner Report Info Referenced in the Report National Citizens Inquiry (NCI) Investigation: Are Children Safe in Canada April 30, 2025 Report ID: Publication Date No. Of Pages: NCI-R-04 April 30, 2024 1267 March 31, 2023 Report National Citizens Inquiry (NCI) Investigation: Are Children Safe in Canada April 30, 2025 Main Topic Purpose and Need for the NCI The National Citizens Inquiry (NCI) was established in response to growing public concerns over the Canadian government’s handling of the COVID-19 event. As the COVID-19 emergency measures unfolded, questions arose regarding the appropriateness and efficacy of the measures implemented, including lockdowns, mandates, and the deployment of COVID-19 “vaccines.” These concerns fuelled the need for a thorough examination of the impact these policies had on health, the economy, on society and civil liberties. The NCI, conceived as an independent and citizen led initiative, sought to comprehensively investigate these issues. Its primary purpose was to provide a platform for individuals and experts to share their experiences, insights, and evidence, in order to uncover the truth, hold authorities accountable, and improve future public health responses. On November 28, 2023, the NCI Commissioners released their comprehensive final report, titled Inquiry into the Appropriateness and Efficacy of the COVID-19 Response in Canada . A year later, on November 28, 2024, a supplemental report was issued as part of the NCI’s ongoing efforts to address new and emerging concerns related to the COVID-19 investigation. Having completed its original mandate of investigating the appropriateness and efficacy of the COVID-19 measures, the NCI expanded its focus. After consulting with a broad range of Canadians, the NCI recognized a significant public concern regarding the current state of children's safety in Canada. Consequently, the NCI undertook a new investigation specifically aimed at evaluating and safeguarding the well-being of children across the country. One Line Summary Heading 2 Synopsis Heading 2

  • Voth | National Citizens Ar

    Witness Testimony Keywords from Transcript Premature Ventilation Concern, Oxygen Shortage Explanation, STARS Air Transfer, Anesthesiologist Availability Issue, Mask Versus Ventilator Dispute, Ivermectin Request Refusal, Proning Improvement Observation, ICU Sepsis Infection, Organ Failure From Infection, Comfort Care Discussion, Visitation Protocol Denial, COVID Recovered Signage, N95 Mask Requirement, End-Of-Life Restrictions, Ventilator Removal Dispute Included in the Report: Ms. Martha Voth Private Citizen Personal Experience Witness ID: NCI-W-097 Hearing Winnipeg Manitoba Date: April 14, 2023 Report Inquiry into the Appropriateness and Efficacy of the COVID-19 Response in Canada; November 2023 Main Topic Testimony alleging premature ventilation, denial of in-person access due to protocol, refusal of requested treatments, ICU-acquired infection, and restrictive end-of-life conditions during her husband’s COVID hospitalization. One Line Summary Martha Voth testified that her husband was ventilated despite apparent improvement on oxygen, later developed a fatal ICU infection, and that strict hospital protocols limited family access and treatment options before his death. Synopsis Martha Voth testified that in May 2021 her husband Alvin, age 66, was admitted to Bethesda Hospital after testing positive for COVID-19 and experiencing breathing difficulty. She stated that although he reported feeling improved on oxygen via face mask, physicians decided to intubate and ventilate him. According to her testimony, she was told this decision was influenced by oxygen supply limitations, anesthesiologist shift availability, and the imminent arrival of a STARS air ambulance. She further testified that STARS personnel allegedly questioned why ventilation was necessary, as he appeared stable on oxygen. After transfer to Health Sciences Centre in Winnipeg, Alvin remained in a medically induced coma. Voth testified that she requested ivermectin but was told only “scientifically and medically proven” treatments would be used. She described daily updates, video calls, and observations that indicated improved his vital statistics. On June 8, she was informed that infected IV ports had caused a bloodstream infection and organ failure. On June 10, the family was asked to consider comfort care. She testified that a sign reading “COVID recovered” was posted on his room door and that staff acknowledged the fatal infection was ICU-acquired rather than active COVID. Voth further testified that when reporting temporarily improved his condition, the family was required to leave due to protocol. On June 25, after being told he would not survive the day, the family gathered at his bedside and ultimately agreed to withdrawal of life support after midnight. She stated that staff initially refused to remove the ventilator tubing fully due to COVID transmission concerns but relented after discussion. Alvin died approximately seven minutes after life support was removed. Voth concluded that in her view, continued oxygen mask support rather than ventilation may have altered the outcome and that rigid hospital protocols prevented potentially beneficial family presence and alternative treatment consideration. 🔎 How to Search the Transcript Click the “Read Transcript” button to open the witness testimony in your browser. Once the transcript PDF is open, you can search for any word or phrase within the document using your browser’s search feature: Windows: Press Ctrl + F Mac: Press Command (⌘) + F A small search box will appear. Type the word or phrase you are looking for, and the browser will highlight every occurrence within the transcript. This makes it easy to quickly locate specific topics, names, or statements within the testimony.

  • NCI-R-04-Item-5-1 | National Citizens Ar

    5.1 Education and School Environment Intentionally Left Blank Report Content Reader Page 📄 Note to Readers The content presented on this page has been adapted for online viewing and navigation. Due to formatting limitations within the web display system, certain elements—such as layout, spacing, and visual structure—may differ slightly from the original report. For the complete and fully formatted version, we encourage you to download the official PDF available on the Report Information page. The PDF reflects the report exactly as it was originally written and published.

  • Beaudry | National Citizens Ar

    Witness Testimony Keywords from Transcript risk matrix modeling, root cause analysis, scientific process critique, mitigation effectiveness assessment, age-stratified COVID risk, vaccine risk-benefit calculation, lockdown comparison Sweden, ICU capacity analysis, Cochrane mask review, Charter rights suspension, stakeholder engagement, cognitive dissonance, financial cost escalation, liability transfer contracts, governance accountability Included in the Report: Mr. Dean Beaudry Risk Management Professional Expert Witness ID: NCI-W-165 Hearing Red Deer Alberta Date: April 26, 2023 Report Inquiry into the Appropriateness and Efficacy of the COVID-19 Response in Canada; November 2023 Main Topic Risk management analysis of COVID-19 policies, mitigation effectiveness, governance accountability, and economic consequences. One Line Summary Retired risk manager applies industrial risk assessment frameworks to evaluate COVID mitigation policies, concluding governance and accountability failures. Synopsis Dean Beaudry, a retired project manager with approximately 30 years of experience in large-scale industrial risk assessment and incident investigation, presented a structured analysis applying risk management principles to COVID-19 policy decisions. Using root cause analysis and risk matrix methodology, he argued that Canadian pandemic responses failed to follow established scientific and risk management processes. He identified key root causes as dismissal of balancing procedures, suppression of dissenting expert opinions, undue authority under emergency powers, and what he described as a breakdown in governance accountability and ethical standards. Mr. Beaudry compared COVID mortality risk to other familiar national risks, such as accidental death, using government data to assess probability and consequence. He emphasized age stratification, pre-existing conditions, and comparative risk positioning on a matrix framework. He evaluated mitigation measures including vaccination, lockdowns, masks, and ICU capacity expansion, arguing that effectiveness assessments were not transparently conducted or updated as real-world data became available. He referenced international comparisons, including Sweden and certain U.S. states, to question the impact of lockdowns, and discussed vaccine adverse event statistics using official reporting figures. He further addressed governance and accountability, contrasting corporate executive liability structures with political decision-making during the pandemic. He cited financial impacts including increased public debt, cost-of-living escalation, and pharmaceutical revenue growth, arguing that consequence models were asymmetrical and lacked direct accountability for decision-makers. Throughout his testimony, he emphasized stakeholder engagement, evidence-based decision labeling (fact, opinion, assumption), and detachment from emotion in high-stakes policy decisions, concluding that failures in values, transparency, and structured decision-making processes contributed to national harm. 🔎 How to Search the Transcript Click the “Read Transcript” button to open the witness testimony in your browser. Once the transcript PDF is open, you can search for any word or phrase within the document using your browser’s search feature: Windows: Press Ctrl + F Mac: Press Command (⌘) + F A small search box will appear. Type the word or phrase you are looking for, and the browser will highlight every occurrence within the transcript. This makes it easy to quickly locate specific topics, names, or statements within the testimony.

  • NCI-R-02-Item-7-5-3 | National Citizens Ar

    7.5.3 Epidemiology 101 in the COVID-19 Era 7.5.3 Epidemiology 101 in the COVID-19 Era Introduction The concept of epidemiology dates back to Hippocrates, who observed that by and large, there were two types of diseases: endemic diseases, which occur continually in the population, and epidemic diseases, whose occurrences are sporadic, such as infections with unprecedented symptoms. Although the science of epidemiology has made much progress since antiquity, understanding the occurrence and the evolution of a new disease that creates significant morbidity and mortality is still a huge challenge. The occurrence of a new pathogen—its transmission in human populations, the interaction with the infected host leading to diseases of varying seriousness, and the ultimate resolution of an epidemic as it progresses to the endemic state—is a highly complex multifactorial phenomena whose driving forces are difficult to identify. The relative contribution of the various factors is also very difficult to measure. We have learned a lot since the beginning of the modern scientific adventure, yet our knowledge is still very limited. The paradigm of modern reductionist materialism, starting with Descartes, is that the world is like a machine whose parts interact with one another according to specific laws of nature written in the language of mathematics. According to this paradigm, all we need to do is identify the components and discover how they interact with one another. With that understanding, it‘s assumed we can control the world. That worldview has several shortfalls as it applies, for example, to the science of epidemiology and as it converges at the intersection of statistics, physics, biology, engineering, psychology, sociology, and politics. The many unknowns in all of the parts of this idealized machine, let alone in the ways they interact, make any modelling attempts to describe and predict how that works is at best naive, if not totally misleading, in many respects. A flurry of mainstream media commentators took centre stage to project the illusion that epidemiology was a mature science able to predict the evolution and control of pandemics with sophisticated models fuelled by powerful computing. The reality was that what we learned about epidemiology over the past decades had not made our understanding of the COVID-19 pandemic any different than previous pandemics. This illusion of knowledge fooled many people into thinking that they could attribute the rise and fall of epidemic waves to specific human interventions or lack thereof. The main innovation during the COVID-19 pandemic was the questionable deployment of the RT-PCR diagnostic as a proxy to follow the epidemic waves. Strangely, instead of monitoring the waves of sick people, public health focused their attention on the presence of a viral genetic sequence to define a “case,” irrespective of its consequence on morbidity and mortality. Moreover, despite the poor predictive power of the RT-PCR tests to inform disease progression, they were used in attributing deaths from COVID-19 to respiratory illnesses of all kinds and without formal demonstration. This created systematic errors of attribution that biased official statistics all over the world. Over-reliance on Modelling We were misled by models. Without delving into too many details, it is necessary to discuss the concept of viral transmission. The physicochemical interaction of an ill-defined biological agent, the virus—which is sensitive to all kinds of environmental conditions, like UV and humidity—travels in the air to enter the airway of another biological being, which will interact with this virus in different ways, depending on the robustness of the mucosal immune system challenged with an unknown viral load. Combining all these parameters, which we cannot properly measure in a web of interactions, quickly becomes a combinatorial explosion of probabilities that are impossible to determine. Assuming we could measure all of the parameters, which we cannot, modelling is then challenged by the mathematical laws governing the interaction of the different components. A relatively simple example is the law of fluid dynamics to estimate the virus transmission in the air, depending on the gravitational force, wind velocity, and humidity. As the equations cannot be fully resolved, we have to assume several measurements. Without those precise measures, what are we going to input as a modelling parameter? The bottom line is that modelling is a useful tool to generate a working hypothesis, based on approximate assessment, to be validated by empirical measures. Modelling cannot make accurate predictions of complex systems. The limitation is not only the computing power but also the uncertainty about the input parameters to run the model. If the assumptions are incorrect, the output of the model is useless for prediction and is referred to as a GIGO model (garbage in, garbage out). The over-reliance on models can be due to the difficulty in testing model predictions experimentally or due to the time involved to collect data before the model‘s accuracy can be formally assessed. Nonetheless, when a modeller consistently misses the target by a long shot, it would be wise to question the assumptions and mathematical process used to produce its prediction. A stunning example was the misleading prediction that resulted from inaccurate modelling. This modelling team had been repeatedly off target in their predictions for more than 10 years: notably in the last flu pandemic of 2009 and the mad cow disease debacle that led to the unnecessary slaughter of cattle herds and huge economic losses for UK farmers. Proper Monitoring of Pandemic Progression It follows that we must be very wary of modelling. The only way to determine if any human intervention will influence the progression of a pandemic is to carry out well-designed observational studies in randomized trials whenever possible to eliminate the unknown influence of confounding factors, while carefully avoiding random errors and monitoring systematic errors resulting from selection or information biases. Only true experts with established credentials and a track record can generate and properly interpret those epidemiological studies. Many of those experts informed us of what to expect by making analogies with similar epidemics of the past. The inescapable conclusion of the careful analyses of the best experts, like Prof. Denis Rancourt and Pierre Chaillot, was that there were no pandemics of extraordinary magnitude in 2020–2023, as the authorities promulgated for those three years. The scale of the pandemic was exaggerated, and in rich countries—with notable exceptions such as Sweden, Japan, and a few American states—the health measures deployed caused more damage to the health of populations than COVID-19 itself. Although Sweden had a bad episode in long-term care homes during the first wave in early 2020, they refrained from imposing lockdowns and ended up with much better public health outcomes. Statistics compiled at the global level showed that the median age of people who died of COVID-19 exceeded the age of life expectancy and that the vast majority of seriously ill people had several other pathologies. This led Richard Horton, editor-in-chief of the Lancet , to declare in his September 26, 2020, op-ed that the COVID-19 pandemic was truly a syndemic. That is, COVID-19 disproportionately affected the most vulnerable. Healthy young people were more than 1000 times less likely to be seriously ill or die from it. In these circumstances, he was advocating for more nuanced public health measures, as did the signatories to the Great Barrington Declaration. Furthermore, the peak of excess deaths observed in different regions of the world coincided with the drastic measures put in place to manage the perceived threat. It‘s almost impossible that those excess deaths were caused by the dissemination of a deadly virus which didn‘t spread across borders and remained in discrete locations within a state or across states. The drastic measures included (1) withholding early treatments, (2) inappropriate use of ventilators that restored anoxia in COVID-19 patients deprived of early treatments, (3) withholding antibiotics to treat incidental bacterial pneumonia, and (4) comfort end-of-life treatments for patients deemed incurable. An accurate account of the COVID-19 pandemic revealed the story of a statistics fraud. What did they count? The definition of pandemic was changed. It became a statistical pandemic with cases. After changing the definition in 2009 by ignoring the gravity criteria and only counting numbers of sick people, the WHO further changed it in 2020 to count cases—including people who may not have been sick. Looking at all-cause mortality adjusted for the age pyramid, we note that 2020 was among the lowest since that statistic has been recorded. Nothing happened, anywhere in the world. As for hospital saturation: for example, in France, even with the dubious attribution of hospitalization due to COVID-19, those patients made up only about two per cent of hospital occupancy. The only apparent hospital saturation was induced by an administrative decision to send all the respiratory-symptom patients (up to three million in France) to only seven of the 1500 hospitals. Because of the planning already in place in anticipation of COVID-19 waves, hospitals were emptied, and people avoided them due to fear. As a result, the occupancy was much lower for many months—for example, 50 per cent empty in April 2020. No pandemic was evident when measured by an increase in respiratory disease by the sentinel network, a monitoring system. To put the data in perspective, during the worst previously reported pandemics, the sentinel system recorded up to 800 cases per 100,000 population, like in 2014–2015. During the COVID-19 pandemic, the number never exceeded 150 cases per 100,000 population. If one adhered to the definition of epidemic as an excess number of sick people, there was no epidemic in 2020, 2021, and 2022. Pandemic by Alleged Fraudulent Testing and Attribution of COVID-19 Cases Mainstream media reported alarming surges in COVID-19 deaths worldwide, which were determined not solely through initial RT-PCR testing but by the WHO‘s coding ICD-11, implemented on January 31, 2020. This method was seen as a broad and scientifically questionable way of attributing deaths to COVID-19, often based on superficial symptom diagnoses with or without confirmation via RT-PCR testing. When all respiratory infections were broadly categorized as COVID-19 cases, it led to the creation of misleading “epidemic“ curves on the Our World in Data website. In reality, the spread of a respiratory virus infection did not align with synchronous events in numerous countries; some were merely delayed in adopting the ICD-11 code, while others had not yet implemented rigorous health measures. The statistics showed that following the implementation of ICD-11, all other respiratory diseases seemed to gradually disappear and become COVID-19, even when the virus had not been detected. Perverse financial incentives appeared to trigger a diligent transfer of coding attribution. There was an increase in deaths in some places, like France, that had instituted strict measures in April 2020, but not in other countries, like Germany, that didn‘t implement those measures. The so-called first waves occurred in a minority of countries or regions. This could be seen all across Europe and even across different provinces in France, as only 14 out of 100 provinces showed excess deaths, and the spike of excess deaths correlated with the stringency of implementing health measures. The same thing happened in the USA. Furthermore, excess deaths were overrepresented in “deaths at home“ due to the lack of treatment because sick people refrained from going to the hospital. Even if most were attributed to COVID-19, there was no proof because autopsies were not performed. For example, there were 5200 deaths at home during the COVID-19 period in France, and 4800 of those deaths were from “stroke and heart attack, non-treated“ during the same period in a given database, while another database reported up to 6000 deaths from stroke and heart attack. Therefore, every one of the 5200 deaths at home could be accounted for by the lack of treatment. In the same vein, the reported 5000 excess deaths in LTC homes for the elderly were equivalent to the number of people treated with midazolam instead of Rivotril, as the stock had been exhausted by the U.K., the USA, and Canada. The rationale was that COVID-19 was a deadly, untreatable disease. Therefore, hospitals would be saturated, and there would be no room to treat the sick elderly; instead the reasoning was give them palliative care for this deadly incurable disease. In France, the most prevalent place of excess deaths was in hospital. An incredible spike of 6000 out of 7000 excess deaths in three days was reported, with 3000 on the same day. This can only be explained by two reasons: (1) people coming to the hospital were already very sick, and (2) the common treatment in ICU to put patients on ventilators was associated with a high mortality rate. The three causes described—denial of early treatments, ventilators, and palliative care—accounted for the bulk of excess deaths. The RT-PCR tests were the driver of the statistical fraud. A test was not the reality. For example, the pregnancy test although very accurate has both false positive and false negative results. If we tested everyone, we would get falsely positive pregnant men and falsely negative pregnant women. We required additional medical data to establish the reliability of the RT-PCR test. By testing everyone, including those without symptoms, we identified a substantial group of asymptomatic COVID-19 cases who were even believed to be capable of spreading the virus. This raised questions about how they could transmit the illness if they didn‘t carry an infectious virus but rather viral RNA sequences. If non-ill individuals who tested positive could transmit their non-sickness to others, it implied that everyone had the potential to be a source of infection. Moreover, the RT-PCR test had not undergone formal validation with a gold standard, as was the case with pregnancy tests. Say the PCR test is 95 per cent reliable, and we tested everybody indiscriminately and found that both asymptomatic and symptomatic people were positive, on average, less than 5 per cent of the time. We would say, then, that the test lacks coherence. Positive PCR testing over-represented the asymptomatic—detecting, more frequently, people who were not sick while missing people with symptoms—75 per cent of the time. Therefore, these symptoms were most likely not representative of COVID-19 disease. It was a “case-demic.“ During the Omicron phase, the percentage of positive RT-PCR tests increased dramatically to more than 30 per cent in France. Was it truly due to increased viral circulation, or was it from modifying the testing protocol? In France, the combination of RT-PCR tests, COVID-19 vaccines, and the vaccine pass produced strange epidemic curves that were better explained by human behaviour because the RT-PCR tests were not coherent. Putting the vaccine pass in place created an artificial vaccine efficacy. The only efficacy seen in the randomized clinical trials (RCTs) in France was a reduction in RT-PCR positive tests. If vaccinated people were not obliged to get tested, a bias of positivity of unvaccinated people who were obliged to get tested would be created. Similarly, when it was revealed that the vaccine was not preventing transmission and that the vaccine efficacy waned over time, people who were anxious about the possibility of infection, got boosted. At the same time, people who refused boosters, which were mandatory for an up-to-date vaccine pass, had to be tested more often. As a result, the boosted people tested less than the double-vaccinated or the unvaccinated, and that created the illusion that the booster worked. However, as soon as the vaccine pass was lifted, the curves inverted because the boosted people, being more anxious, were testing themselves more often than the double-vaccinated or unvaccinated people that no longer got tested when it was not mandatory. It was all a statistical illusion. The chilling implication of this rigorous statistical analysis of the official data was that it was a sham pandemic perpetrated by the military and administrative state through a sophisticated psychological operation against the civilian population. While some people may have died from a virus, which probably escaped from the Wuhan lab, the deaths did not show up in the excess-death data. Deaths from the three other declared pandemics since WW II also did not show up in excess-death data. But wars did, intense heat waves did, and earthquakes did, yet proclaimed pandemics did not, except the Spanish flu. A pandemic should be characterized by a significant excess of sick and dead people, not unreliable RT-PCR positive cases. The definition was perverted by an unvalidated display of pandemic waves that instilled fear in people and compelled them to submit to never-before-accepted NPIs as a prelude to the vaccination campaign that was sold as a relief to the unsustainable harmful health measures. Recommendations Due to the confusion caused by improper testing for COVID-19, particularly using unvalidated RT-PCR testing, the following recommendations were made: A. Pause the use of RT-PCR or rapid antigen testing when it is not accompanied by a thorough medical evaluation of disease symptoms. B. Conduct a rigorous validation of RT-PCR testing , including standardized cultivation of the active virus. Establish a defined threshold for the number of amplification cycles that show due use. Considering the confusion that arose from the lack of transparency in official public data, the following recommendations are added: C. Ensure that all government data is consistently and transparently shared with the public for independent evaluation by qualified experts in epidemiology and statistics. D. Make any disparities between data analysis , done by the government and data analysis done by independent citizens, subject to review by an impartial advisory committee composed of experts in epidemiology and data analysis. This committee should be regularly vetted through public forums to maintain transparency and accountability. Report Content Reader Page 📄 Note to Readers The content presented on this page has been adapted for online viewing and navigation. Due to formatting limitations within the web display system, certain elements—such as layout, spacing, and visual structure—may differ slightly from the original report. For the complete and fully formatted version, we encourage you to download the official PDF available on the Report Information page. The PDF reflects the report exactly as it was originally written and published.

  • Trozzi | National Citizens Ar

    Detailed Commissioner Report Info Referenced in the Report National Citizens Inquiry (NCI) Investigation: Are Children Safe in Canada April 30, 2025 Report ID: Publication Date No. Of Pages: NCI-R-04 April 30, 2024 1267 April 1, 2023 Report National Citizens Inquiry (NCI) Investigation: Are Children Safe in Canada April 30, 2025 Main Topic Purpose and Need for the NCI The National Citizens Inquiry (NCI) was established in response to growing public concerns over the Canadian government’s handling of the COVID-19 event. As the COVID-19 emergency measures unfolded, questions arose regarding the appropriateness and efficacy of the measures implemented, including lockdowns, mandates, and the deployment of COVID-19 “vaccines.” These concerns fuelled the need for a thorough examination of the impact these policies had on health, the economy, on society and civil liberties. The NCI, conceived as an independent and citizen led initiative, sought to comprehensively investigate these issues. Its primary purpose was to provide a platform for individuals and experts to share their experiences, insights, and evidence, in order to uncover the truth, hold authorities accountable, and improve future public health responses. On November 28, 2023, the NCI Commissioners released their comprehensive final report, titled Inquiry into the Appropriateness and Efficacy of the COVID-19 Response in Canada . A year later, on November 28, 2024, a supplemental report was issued as part of the NCI’s ongoing efforts to address new and emerging concerns related to the COVID-19 investigation. Having completed its original mandate of investigating the appropriateness and efficacy of the COVID-19 measures, the NCI expanded its focus. After consulting with a broad range of Canadians, the NCI recognized a significant public concern regarding the current state of children's safety in Canada. Consequently, the NCI undertook a new investigation specifically aimed at evaluating and safeguarding the well-being of children across the country. One Line Summary Heading 2 Synopsis Heading 2

  • Chisholm | National Citizens Ar

    Detailed Commissioner Report Info Referenced in the Report National Citizens Inquiry (NCI) Investigation: Are Children Safe in Canada April 30, 2025 Report ID: Publication Date No. Of Pages: NCI-R-04 April 30, 2024 1267 March 16, 2023 Report National Citizens Inquiry (NCI) Investigation: Are Children Safe in Canada April 30, 2025 Main Topic Purpose and Need for the NCI The National Citizens Inquiry (NCI) was established in response to growing public concerns over the Canadian government’s handling of the COVID-19 event. As the COVID-19 emergency measures unfolded, questions arose regarding the appropriateness and efficacy of the measures implemented, including lockdowns, mandates, and the deployment of COVID-19 “vaccines.” These concerns fuelled the need for a thorough examination of the impact these policies had on health, the economy, on society and civil liberties. The NCI, conceived as an independent and citizen led initiative, sought to comprehensively investigate these issues. Its primary purpose was to provide a platform for individuals and experts to share their experiences, insights, and evidence, in order to uncover the truth, hold authorities accountable, and improve future public health responses. On November 28, 2023, the NCI Commissioners released their comprehensive final report, titled Inquiry into the Appropriateness and Efficacy of the COVID-19 Response in Canada . A year later, on November 28, 2024, a supplemental report was issued as part of the NCI’s ongoing efforts to address new and emerging concerns related to the COVID-19 investigation. Having completed its original mandate of investigating the appropriateness and efficacy of the COVID-19 measures, the NCI expanded its focus. After consulting with a broad range of Canadians, the NCI recognized a significant public concern regarding the current state of children's safety in Canada. Consequently, the NCI undertook a new investigation specifically aimed at evaluating and safeguarding the well-being of children across the country. One Line Summary Heading 2 Synopsis Heading 2

  • NCI-R-04-Item-4-7-2 | National Citizens Ar

    4.7.2 Traditional Childhood Vaccine Safety Concerns 4.7.2 Traditional Childhood Vaccine Safety Concerns Reference to the Original NCI Report The Inquiry into the Appropriateness and Efficacy of the COVID-19 Response in Canada (November 28, 2023) primarily addressed concerns regarding COVID-19 vaccines but also identified broader systemic issues in vaccine safety. Testimonies from the NCI Vancouver Hearings expanded the discussion to include traditional childhood vaccines, focusing on safety protocols, adverse event reporting systems, and the cumulative effects of increasingly complex vaccine schedules. Introduction The Vancouver NCI hearings brought renewed attention to the safety of traditional childhood vaccines, a topic that has long been overshadowed by debates surrounding newer vaccines, such as those developed in response to the COVID-19 event. While the original NCI report primarily focused on issues related to COVID-19 vaccines, testimonies from experts and advocates at the NCI Vancouver Hearings broadened the conversation to encompass systemic challenges in the evaluation, monitoring, and implementation of childhood immunization programs. Prominent experts, including Dr. Paul Thomas, Dr. Byram Bridle, Dr. Jessica Rose, Dr. Michelle Perro, and Dr. Stephen Malthouse, raised significant concerns about the current state of vaccine safety protocols. Their testimonies illuminated critical gaps, such as insufficient safety testing, the systemic underreporting of adverse events, and the failure to adequately assess the cumulative risks of vaccine adjuvants and contaminants like aluminum and glyphosate. Witnesses emphasized that these shortcomings not only undermine vaccine safety but also erode public trust in vaccination programs. A central theme of the testimonies was the lack of rigorous placebo controlled trials to evaluate the long-term effects of traditional childhood vaccines. Witnesses explained that many vaccines are tested against older vaccines or an adjuvant rather than inert placebos, a practice that obscures potential risks and fails to provide a clear understanding of safety profiles. This issue is compounded by the systemic underreporting of adverse events through monitoring systems like VAERS, which capture only a fraction of vaccine related injuries. Experts highlighted how this underreporting distorts public health data and limits the ability to identify and address potential safety concerns. The testimonies also shed light on the cumulative risks associated with expanded vaccination schedules. Witnesses expressed concern that the administration of multiple vaccines within short time-frames places an unacknowledged burden on children’s developing immune and neurological systems. Adjuvants like aluminum, used to enhance immune responses, were flagged as potential contributors to neuro-developmental disorders, while glyphosate contamination was linked to disruptions in the gut-brain-axis, immune function, and overall health. Additionally, no studies have been conducted on the combined effects of these vaccines, even though they are now administered in groups of three to four at a time. Beyond technical critiques, witnesses like Dr. Malthouse and Dr. Thomas emphasized the ethical dimensions of vaccine safety, particularly the importance of informed consent and parental authority. They argued that current policies often marginalize parents, undermining their ability to make decisions in the best interest of their children. Transparency in vaccine safety evaluations and regulatory processes was identified as a crucial step toward rebuilding public trust and fostering collaborative decision-making. This section synthesizes the insights and concerns raised by witnesses, providing a comprehensive examination of traditional childhood vaccine safety. Their testimonies underscore the pressing need for systemic reforms, including more rigorous safety evaluations, improved adverse event monitoring, and policies that prioritize transparency and individual choice. By addressing these critical issues, public health authorities can better ensure the safety and well-being of children, while restoring confidence in vaccination programs. Discussion of Witness Testimonies Dr. Paul Thomas Overview of Testimony Dr. Paul Thomas, a board certified paediatrician and leading advocate for informed vaccine choice, presented evidence-based testimony on the health effects of traditional childhood vaccines. Drawing from his clinical experience and research, Dr. Thomas highlighted significant disparities in health outcomes between vaccinated and unvaccinated children. His testimony raised critical concerns about vaccine safety testing, the use of aluminum adjuvants, underreporting of adverse events, and the erosion of informed consent and parental rights. According to Dr. Thomas: 54% of US children are “chronically ill” 13% require special education 16% have a developmental disorder 11% have ADHD 1 in 35 have autism Millions have asthma and eczema 1500 new cases of cancer in US children are reported annually Infant mortality in the US is the highest of any high income country Autism was reported in 1 in 10,000 children in 1970 and was 1 in 35 in 2020. In 2020 a review of Dr Thomas’ entire paediatric practise over a decade was subject to a published peer review article. In his practise there were 561 unvaccinated children and 2763 variably vaccinated, mostly with his “vaccine friendly” protocol. The cumulative number of office visits over the ten year period was reported, separated by vaccinated and unvaccinated children. The results were as follows: Vaccinated Unvaccinated Asthma 350 50 Allergic rhinitis 400 50 Urticaria and Eczema 680 180 Dermatitis 750 500 Behavioural problems 320 60 ADHD 160 0 Anaemia 1000 150 Sinusitis 110 20 Respiratory infections 5500 1500 Otitis media 3100 1100 Conjunctivitis 1000 400 Gastroenteritis 700 130 Other infections 2000 700 Key Points from Testimony Health Outcomes in Vaccinated vs. Unvaccinated Children: Shared findings from his peer-reviewed study, which revealed lower rates of chronic conditions such as asthma, ADHD, and autism in unvaccinated children compared to their vaccinated peers. Highlighted that vaccinated children showed higher incidences of eczema, developmental delays, and autoimmune disorders. Discussed the improved health trajectories of children following his modified vaccine schedule, which spaces out vaccines and reduces exposure to adjuvants and preservatives. Dr. Thomas originally promoted a modified vaccine schedule in 2016 known as the "Vaccine-Friendly Plan." Since then, based on research and clinical data from his practice, he has moved away from that plan and now emphasizes that unvaccinated children appear to be the healthiest group overall. Aluminum Adjuvants and Neurotoxicity: Criticized the use of aluminum as a vaccine adjuvant, emphasizing its neurotoxic properties and potential harm to developing brains. Cited research linking aluminum exposure to neuro-developmental disorders such as autism, especially in infants with immature detoxification systems. Highlighted that the cumulative aluminum doses from the standard vaccine schedule often exceed safety thresholds established by regulatory agencies like the FDA. Adverse Event Reporting Gaps: Identified systemic flaws in vaccine safety monitoring systems, such as VAERS, noting that they capture only 1–2% of actual vaccine-related injuries. Emphasized that the underreporting of adverse events distorts public perception of vaccine safety and hinders efforts to identify and mitigate risks. Raised concerns about the lack of mechanisms to track long-term adverse effects, leaving critical gaps in safety evaluations. Informed Consent and Parental Rights: Advocated for transparent and accessible communication of vaccine risks and benefits to empower parents in making informed decisions. Criticized policies and practices that pressure or coerce parents into following the standard vaccine schedule without considering individual health needs. Emphasized the importance of respecting parental authority and the right to choose what is best for their children’s health. Call for Individualized Vaccine Approaches: Argued that a "one-size-fits-all" approach to childhood vaccination ignores the unique health needs of individual children, increasing the risk of adverse outcomes. Advocates for informed consent and careful evaluation of vaccine risks, emphasizing that unvaccinated children in his practice were the healthiest. While he previously supported personalized vaccine schedules, his more recent findings have led him to question the safety and benefit of routine childhood vaccination altogether. Dr. Thomas’s testimony highlighted systemic deficiencies in traditional vaccine safety protocols, including inadequate safety testing, gaps in adverse event reporting, and reliance on neurotoxic adjuvants like aluminum. Dr. Byram Bridle Overview of Testimony Dr. Byram Bridle, a virologist and vaccinologist with extensive experience in vaccine development and safety research, provided testimony critiquing the current oversight and evaluation processes for traditional childhood vaccines. His testimony focused on the inadequacy of safety testing, the risks associated with aluminum adjuvants, and the bio-distribution of vaccine components. Drawing on scientific studies and his expertise, Dr. Bridle highlighted systemic flaws in vaccine safety protocols and called for reforms to address these critical issues. Key Points from Testimony Insufficient Safety Testing: Criticized the lack of long-term, placebo-controlled trials using inert substances, noting that such trials are essential to identify potential risks and long-term health outcomes. Explained that vaccines are often tested against older vaccines and adjuvants instead of true placebos, obscuring safety concerns and preventing a clear assessment of their risk profiles. There are no studies have been conducted on the combined effects of these vaccines, even though they are now administered in groups of three to four at a time. Flaws in Regulatory Oversight: Highlighted selective reporting practices by health agencies, which often fail to provide the public with a comprehensive understanding of vaccine safety. Argued that regulatory bodies do not adequately enforce protocols to ensure vaccines undergo independent and unbiased safety evaluations. Aluminum Adjuvants and Neurotoxicity: Raised concerns about the widespread use of aluminum as a vaccine adjuvant, emphasizing its neurotoxic properties and potential to cause long-term harm. Cited studies showing that aluminum can accumulate in the brain and other organs, leading to neuroinflammation and contributing to conditions such as autism, ADHD, and other developmental disorders. Pointed out that the cumulative aluminum exposure from multiple vaccines often exceeds established safety thresholds, particularly for young children with underdeveloped detoxification systems. Bio-distribution Concerns: Discussed evidence showing that vaccine components, including adjuvants like aluminum, do not remain localized at the injection site as previously assumed but travel to various organs throughout the body. Warned that this systemic spread of vaccine components could disrupt neurological and immune systems, leading to unintended health consequences. Cumulative Risk Assessment: Emphasized the need to evaluate the combined effects of administering multiple vaccines within short timeframe and the administration of combination vaccines, particularly in young children who are most vulnerable to toxic exposures. There are no studies conducted on the combined effects of these vaccines, even though they are now administered in groups of three to four at a time. Argued that the current vaccination schedules fail to account for the cumulative impact of adjuvants, preservatives, and other components on overall health and development. Call for Reforms: Advocated for stricter safety standards and independent oversight in vaccine development to ensure unbiased and transparent evaluations. Urged regulatory agencies to prioritize public health over industry interests by enforcing rigorous safety protocols and providing accurate data on vaccine risks. Dr. Bridle’s testimony underscored the critical need for comprehensive reforms in traditional vaccine safety protocols. By addressing gaps in safety testing, regulatory oversight, and cumulative risk assessment, his insights highlighted the importance of establishing higher safety standards to protect children’s health and restore public trust in vaccination programs. Dr. Jessica Rose Overview of Testimony Dr. Jessica Rose, a computational biologist and expert in vaccine adverse event data analysis, provided testimony that focused on systemic weaknesses in vaccine safety monitoring and the potential risks associated with vaccine components and contamination. Drawing from her extensive experience analyzing data from the Vaccine Adverse Event Reporting System (VAERS), Dr. Rose highlighted significant underreporting of vaccine related adverse events and raised concerns about the role of aluminum adjuvants and contaminants such as glyphosate and DNA fragments in vaccines. Dr. Rose’s analysis of VAERS data: VAERS (Vaccine Adverse Events Database) is a US program for vaccine safety monitoring managed by the Centres for disease Control (CDC) and Food and Drug Administration (FDA) though the database is open entries from countries other than the US. Reported adverse events from vaccines averaged approximately 39,000 per year up to the introduction of the COVID-19 mRNA vaccines. In the year following COVID-19 vaccine roll-out, reported adverse reactions rose to 753,047. Deaths reported to VAERS in the decade prior to the mRNA vaccine introduction were approximately 150 per year. In the year following the introduction of the COVID-19 injections, this rose to 10,596. It is estimated that only 1-2% of adverse effects are reported to the VAERS database, meaning the actual numbers are likely much higher, potentially significantly higher. The reluctance to report may stem from the time-consuming nature of the reporting system, as well as active discouragement from medical regulatory and licensing authorities in many cases. It is sometimes argued that the large increase in reports is because a very large number of mRNA vaccinations given during the COVID event, but Dr Rose has analyzed the data to compare reported adverse events for COVID-19 vaccines versus the next commonest vaccine given, the influenza vaccine, normalized by dose. Adverse Events (AES) reported per 1,000,000 doses of influenza vaccine is 55 AES reported per 1,000,000 doses of COVID-19 vaccine is 1378, a difference of 25x. Deaths reported per 1,000,000 influenza vaccinations is 0.3 Deaths reported per 1,000,000 COVID-19 vaccinations is 21, a difference of 70x. Cancers reported per 1,000,000 influenza vaccinations is 0.3 Cancers reported per 1,000,000 COVID-19 vaccinations is 10, a difference of 33x. In addition, the number of cancers reported since 2020 has risen each year since the introduction of the COVID-19 vaccines and shows no evidence of falling. There are increasing anecdotal reports of late stage cancers in younger patients, though the data are not conclusive. Dr. Rose’s Analysis of VAERS Data in Children 0-17 Although healthy children face virtually no risk of dying from COVID-19, and are not significant spreaders of the virus, vaccination for this age group has still been aggressively promoted. VAERS data show a significant increase in adverse event (AE) reports since COVID-19 injections introduction, especially in the 12-17 age group, with a total of 43,743. 14% of these AES are considered “serious”, meaning the child had to have time off school, was hospitalized, or died. A total of 200 deaths have been reported, with 58 of these deaths occurring within 24 hours of injection. An analysis of Canadian data revealed 146 adverse events (AES) reported in children aged 0 to 17. Of these, 55% were classified as serious, and there were 3 reported deaths. These data far exceed the CDC’s normal recall criteria for newly introduced vaccines, but no action has been taken. Key Points from Testimony Adverse Event Reporting in VAERS: Pointed out that VAERS, the primary system for tracking vaccine-related adverse events, captures less than 1–2% of actual incidents, leading to a distorted understanding of vaccine safety. Cited data showing high rates of adverse events linked to aluminum containing vaccines, particularly in young children, including developmental delays, neurological disorders, and other chronic health issues. Criticized the reliance on passive reporting systems like VAERS, which depend on individuals to voluntarily report adverse events, resulting in substantial data gaps. Aluminum Adjuvants and Neuroinflammation: Highlighted the neurotoxic properties of aluminum, commonly used as an adjuvant to enhance immune responses in vaccines. Discussed research linking aluminum exposure to neuroinflammation, which may contribute to developmental and behavioural disorders such as autism and ADHD. Raised concerns about the cumulative effects of aluminum from multiple vaccines administered during early childhood, when detoxification systems are still underdeveloped. • Vaccine Contamination: Dr. Jessica Rose presented findings regarding contaminants in COVID-19 vaccines, including residual DNA fragments resulting from the use of bacterial plasmids in the manufacturing process. She stated that these DNA fragments were introduced when E. coli was used to produce spike protein-encoding plasmids for large-scale vaccine production. Dr. Rose further testified that compendia standards for biological product safety and quality were not adhered to. Warned that these contaminants could have unknown long-term effects on children’s health, including disruptions to immune function and increased risks of autoimmune disorders. Criticized inadequate oversight in vaccine manufacturing processes, calling for stricter regulations and independent monitoring to prevent contamination. Call for Systemic Reforms in Monitoring and Manufacturing: Advocated for the overhaul of vaccine safety monitoring systems to ensure comprehensive data collection and analysis of adverse events. Called for independent investigations into the long-term health effects of vaccine components and contaminants. Emphasized the need for transparency and accountability in vaccine manufacturing and safety evaluations to rebuild public trust. Dr. Rose’s testimony highlighted critical flaws in vaccine safety monitoring and manufacturing, underscoring the urgent need for systemic reforms to protect children’s health. By emphasizing the risks posed by aluminum adjuvants, underreported adverse events, and vaccine contamination, she made a compelling case for improving safety standards and fostering greater transparency in public health policies. Dr. Michelle Perro Overview of Testimony Dr. Michelle Perro, a paediatrician with over four decades of clinical experience and expertise in environmental health, provided a comprehensive critique of traditional childhood vaccine safety during the Vancouver NCI hearings. Her testimony emphasized the interconnectedness of vaccine components, environmental toxins, microbiome health, and the cumulative impacts of medical interventions on children’s long-term development. Drawing from her clinical practice and research, Dr. Perro identified critical gaps in vaccine safety evaluation and highlighted the need for a holistic, integrative approach to addressing systemic failures. Key Points from Testimony Glyphosate and Microbiome Disruption: Highlighted the presence of glyphosate, a widely used herbicide, as a contaminant in vaccines and discussed its adverse effects on the microbiome. Explained how glyphosate disrupts the gut-brain-axis by depleting beneficial gut bacteria and promoting harmful strains, such as Clostridia, which can impair serotonin production, a neurotransmitter essential for mood regulation. Linked microbiome imbalances caused by glyphosate to neurological and developmental disorders, including autism spectrum disorders, anxiety, and depression. Aluminum Adjuvants and Cumulative Toxic Burden: Criticized the widespread use of aluminum as a vaccine adjuvant, emphasizing its neurotoxic properties and the lack of research into its long-term effects on children. Discussed studies showing that aluminum can cross the blood brain barrier, accumulate in the brain, and contribute to neuroinflammation, which is associated with cognitive and behavioural disorders such as ADHD and autism. Warned that current vaccine schedules fail to account for the cumulative toxic burden of multiple vaccine components, including aluminum, administered within short timeframes. Cautioned that the administration of combination vaccines has not been studied. Environmental and Dietary Factors in Vaccine Safety: Addressed the synergistic effects of environmental toxins, such as pesticides and chemicals, with vaccine components, amplifying risks to children’s health. Highlighted how poor diets, rich in processed food and low in essential nutrients, further compromise the gut-brain-axis and exacerbate vaccine-related health challenges. Call for Integrative Research and Transparency: Advocated for independent, integrative research into the cumulative risks posed by vaccine schedules, environmental toxins, and dietary factors. Criticized the lack of transparency in vaccine safety evaluations and called for greater accountability in addressing these systemic issues. The Need for Holistic Solutions: Emphasized the importance of adopting holistic approaches to vaccine safety that consider environmental, dietary, and medical factors in tandem. Urged policymakers to prioritize strategies that support microbiome health, reduce toxic exposures, and educate families on maintaining overall health and resilience. Dr. Perro’s testimony offered a holistic perspective on the intersection of environmental health and vaccine safety. By exposing the systemic failures in evaluating cumulative risks and highlighting the role of the microbiome in children’s health, she underscored the urgent need for comprehensive reforms in vaccine protocols and public health policies to safeguard children’s well-being. Dr. Stephen Malthouse Overview of Testimony Dr. Stephen Malthouse, a family physician with extensive clinical experience, critiqued the safety evaluation and oversight of traditional childhood vaccines. He raised concerns about the lack of rigorous safety testing, systemic underreporting of adverse events, and the influence of pharmaceutical companies on vaccine research and regulatory processes. Key Points from Testimony Insufficient Safety Testing: Highlighted the absence of long-term, placebo controlled trials using inert substances, which obscures the true safety profiles of traditional childhood vaccines. Emphasized the need for independent studies to assess the cumulative risks of vaccine components over time. Adverse Event Reporting Gaps: Criticized current adverse event tracking systems for failing to capture the full scope of vaccine-related injuries, pointing out that many events go unreported. Stressed the need for improved monitoring systems to ensure accurate data collection and analysis. Concerns about Vaccine Adjuvants: Highlighted the neurotoxic properties of aluminum adjuvants commonly used in vaccines and their potential link to chronic illnesses such as autism and ADHD. Warned about the long-term health implications of cumulative aluminum exposure in children. Pharmaceutical Influence on Public Health Policies: Expressed concerns about the influence of pharmaceutical companies on vaccine research, regulatory oversight, and public health recommendations. Called for greater transparency and independence in vaccine development and approval processes to restore public trust. • Parental Authority and Informed Consent: Criticized policies that undermine parental authority by allowing vaccine administration without informed parental consent. Advocated for empowering parents with clear, unbiased information to make informed decisions about their children’s health. Dr. Malthouse’s testimony highlighted significant flaws in traditional vaccine safety protocols and emphasized the need for systemic reforms, including stricter safety standards, improved adverse event tracking, and enhanced transparency in public health decision-making. His insights underscored the importance of empowering families to make informed choices in the best interest of their children. Kathy Stack Overview of Testimony Kathy Stack testified about her experience as a mother of a child with Down syndrome and the health complications he faced following early childhood vaccinations. As an intensive care nurse at the time, she followed standard medical advice but later questioned the impact of vaccines on her son’s health. Her testimony focused on the immediate and long-term effects of vaccination, medical responses, and broader concerns about vaccine safety. Key Points Early Childhood and Initial Health Status: Stack gave birth to her son, in 1989. He was born a healthy 10-pound, 3-ounce baby and was diagnosed with Down syndrome at birth. Despite his diagnosis, he met developmental milestones in his early months. She documented his progress, including smiling and reaching for her face. Adverse Reaction to Vaccination: At three and a half months, she took her son for his first diphtheria, pertussis, and tetanus (DPT) vaccine, following medical recommendations. Within hours of receiving the shot, he developed a high fever and became highly irritable. She treated him with Tylenol and put him to bed but did not initially suspect a severe reaction. • Medical Complications and Concerns: Stack’s concerns about vaccine safety grew as her son’s health issues persisted. She later questioned whether the vaccine may have contributed to developmental and health challenges beyond his Down syndrome diagnosis. Her experience led her to reevaluate her trust in standard medical practices regarding childhood immunization. Kathy Stack’s testimony highlights concerns about vaccine safety, particularly for children with pre-existing conditions such as Down syndrome. As both a mother and a healthcare professional, her perspective illustrates the challenges parents face in making informed medical decisions. Her experience underscores the need for greater transparency and thorough investigation of adverse reactions to childhood vaccinations. Discussion and Analysis of Issues Raised by the Witnesses The Vancouver NCI hearings exposed systemic failures in the safety evaluation, monitoring, and regulatory oversight of traditional childhood vaccines. Witnesses consistently raised concerns about insufficient safety testing, significant underreporting of adverse events, and the cumulative risks posed by adjuvants and contaminants. These issues highlight critical gaps in the existing framework for ensuring vaccine safety and public trust. Insufficient Safety Testing Witnesses, including Dr. Stephen Malthouse and Dr. Byram Bridle, emphasized the lack of long-term, placebo controlled trials using inert substances to assess vaccine safety. Current practices often compare new vaccines to older ones that may already carry risks, obscuring the ability to identify long-term or cumulative health effects. Dr. Malthouse criticized the absence of independent studies assessing the cumulative risks of vaccine components over time. Dr. Bridle explained that the reliance on flawed safety evaluation protocols prevents a clear understanding of the potential neurological and developmental impacts of vaccines, particularly for young children. Underreporting of Adverse Events Systemic underreporting in vaccine monitoring systems, such as VAERS, was a recurring theme. Dr. Jessica Rose highlighted that VAERS captures less than 1–2% of vaccine-related adverse events, creating significant data gaps. This underreporting distorts the safety profile of vaccines and hinders efforts to address potential risks. Dr. Malthouse called for improved monitoring systems and mandatory reporting by healthcare providers to ensure accurate tracking of adverse events. Cumulative Risks of Vaccine Adjuvants and Contaminants The testimonies of Dr. Thomas, Dr. Perro, and Dr. Malthouse raised concerns about the cumulative risks posed by vaccine adjuvants, such as aluminum, and contaminants, such as glyphosate. Dr. Thomas highlighted the neurotoxic properties of aluminum and its links to developmental disorders, including autism and ADHD. Dr. Perro explained how glyphosate contamination disrupts the microbiome and the gut-brain-axis, contributing to neurological and immune dysfunction. Dr. Malthouse emphasized the need for a comprehensive evaluation of the cumulative toxic burden resulting from multiple vaccines administered in short timeframes, and the administration of combination vaccines. Erosion of Trust and Parental Authority Witnesses criticized the lack of transparency in vaccine policy development and the exclusion of parental voices. Dr. Malthouse and Dr. Thomas emphasized the importance of respecting parental authority and providing clear, unbiased information to enable informed consent. Physicians Lack Substantial Knowledge Concerning Vaccines Dr. Paul Thomas and Dr. Stephen Malthouse stated that physicians generally lack substantial knowledge about vaccines and vaccine combinations. Dr. Paul Thomas: He emphasized that physicians are not adequately educated on vaccine safety, especially regarding cumulative risks and aluminum adjuvants. He explained that vaccines are not tested against inert placebos, making it difficult even for doctors to evaluate safety claims accurately. In his updated position, he explicitly stated that after more research, he no longer recommends his former “Vaccine-Friendly Plan,” acknowledging that the data since 2016 shows even that reduced schedule has risks. Dr. Stephen Malthouse: He was even more direct, stating that doctors are not given proper education on vaccines, and are instead “indoctrinated with propaganda”. Dr. Malthouse criticized the practice whereby physicians are often not involved in administering vaccines, resulting in their exclusion from the active decision-making process. He expressed concern that, particularly when public health authorities oversee vaccination programs in schools, medical professionals are sidelined from individualized patient care and consent discussions. He also noted that doctors are not in a position to explain vaccine risks and alternatives to children because they themselves don’t understand the vaccines well enough. Conclusion The testimonies from the Vancouver NCI hearings revealed significant systemic shortcomings in the safety evaluation and oversight of traditional childhood vaccines. Experts identified critical issues, including insufficient safety testing, significant underreporting of adverse events, and the cumulative risks posed by aluminum adjuvants and contaminants like glyphosate. Additionally, witnesses highlighted the erosion of parental trust due to a lack of transparency and the exclusion of parents from decision-making processes. It is essential that healthcare providers receive comprehensive, evidence-based education on the full spectrum of vaccine-related information, including both the known benefits and risks, as well as the unknowns resulting from insufficient long-term safety studies and limited research on combined vaccine schedules. This education must also address concerns related to potentially harmful components, such as aluminum and other adjuvants, whose cumulative effects remain inadequately understood. Ensuring that physicians are properly informed will enable them to engage in transparent, honest communication with parents. In turn, this will support truly informed consent, allowing parents to make decisions that reflect a balanced understanding of both the proven and potential risks and benefits associated with vaccination. These findings underscore the need for comprehensive reforms to ensure that childhood vaccine policies prioritize the safety, health, and well-being of children. By addressing systemic flaws, and fostering open dialogue with families, public health authorities can rebuild confidence in vaccination programs and better protect the youngest members of society. Recommendations Improve Safety Testing: Mandate long-term, placebo-controlled trials using inert substances for all vaccines. Require independent research to assess the cumulative risks of vaccine components, including adjuvants, preservatives and the safety of combination vaccines. Until comprehensive safety testing is completed, a precautionary approach should be adopted. This includes limiting the use of certain vaccines in children, enhancing adverse event monitoring, and ensuring that parents receive full disclosure of both known and unknown risks to support informed decision-making. 2. Enhance Monitoring Systems: Revamp adverse event reporting systems like VAERS to ensure comprehensive and accurate tracking. Implement mandatory reporting requirements for healthcare providers to capture vaccine-related injuries effectively. 3. Reassess Adjuvant and Contaminant Safety: Conduct independent studies into the long-term neurological and developmental effects of aluminum adjuvants. Eliminate glyphosate contamination and harmful substances, such as aluminum, mercury and others from vaccines. 4. Enforce True Informed Consent and Parental Involvement: It is essential that healthcare providers receive comprehensive, evidence-based education on the full spectrum of vaccine-related information, including both the known benefits and risks, as well as the unknowns resulting from insufficient long-term safety studies and limited research on combined vaccine schedules. This education must also address concerns related to potentially harmful components, such as aluminum and other adjuvants, whose cumulative effects remain inadequately understood. Provide parents with clear, evidence-based information about vaccine risks and benefits. Empower parents to make informed decisions regarding the vaccination of their children based on individual health needs rather than standardized schedules. Ensure that vaccinations are no longer administered in schools to uphold parental authority and to prevent children from experiencing undue pressure, whether from school authority figures or from peer influence among classmates. 5. Strengthen Regulatory Oversight: Ensure independent oversight of vaccine safety evaluations to eliminate conflicts of interest. Increase transparency in clinical trial data, regulatory processes, and public health communications to restore trust. Hold pharmaceutical companies accountable for any harms their products cause. 6. Address Cumulative Risks: Develop guidelines to evaluate the cumulative effects of multiple vaccines administered within short time-frames. Prioritize research into the combined impacts of combination vaccines, environmental toxins, dietary factors, and vaccine components on children’s health. 7. Rebuild Trust and Accountability: Foster open dialogue with families and include parents and child development experts in policy-making processes. Promote ethical oversight to ensure vaccine policies prioritize the well-being of children over industry interests. By implementing these recommendations, Canada can establish a safer, more transparent, and family-centred framework for childhood immunization. These changes are critical to addressing public concerns and protecting the health and future of Canadian children. Report Content Reader Page 📄 Note to Readers The content presented on this page has been adapted for online viewing and navigation. Due to formatting limitations within the web display system, certain elements—such as layout, spacing, and visual structure—may differ slightly from the original report. For the complete and fully formatted version, we encourage you to download the official PDF available on the Report Information page. The PDF reflects the report exactly as it was originally written and published.

  • NCI-R-04-Item-4-1-3 | National Citizens Ar

    4.1.3 Teacher and Administrative Bias 4.1.3 Teacher and Administrative Bias Introduction Teacher and administrative bias in schools refers to the subtle or overt influence of personal beliefs, values, or institutional policies on how educators and administrators deliver education and interact with students. In educational contexts, maintaining neutrality is a foundational principle that ensures all students are exposed to balanced and objective instruction. This approach fosters critical thinking, encourages respectful dialogue, and promotes the development of independent thought. However, when bias enters the educational environment, it risks undermining these principles and may create a learning atmosphere where certain perspectives dominate to the exclusion of others. Concerns about teacher and administrative bias are particularly pronounced when addressing sensitive or controversial topics such as gender identity, social justice, environmental activism, or political ideologies. Witnesses at the Vancouver NCI hearings described how certain viewpoints are sometimes presented as definitive or non-negotiable, leaving little room for alternative perspectives. This can create an environment where students feel pressured to conform to specific ideologies, stifling open dialogue and discouraging the exploration of diverse viewpoints. Bias can manifest in various ways, from the content of the curriculum to the interactions between teachers and students. For example, curriculum materials may reflect a single ideological stance, omitting alternative perspectives or critical analyses. Classroom dynamics can also be affected, with educators unintentionally or intentionally promoting specific viewpoints during discussions, thereby influencing how students interpret or engage with complex topics. Furthermore, administrative decisions, such as the adoption of policies or the handling of dissenting opinions from parents or staff, can reinforce perceived biases, eroding trust between schools and their communities. For parents, these biases raise significant concerns about the fairness of education and the role of schools in shaping students’ moral and social values. Many parents view education as a partnership where schools and families work together to prepare children for an open minded and free society. When schools prioritize certain ideologies or exclude parents from decision-making processes, it can strain this partnership and lead to tensions over the perceived erosion of parental rights in guiding their children’s development. The implications of teacher and administrative bias are far-reaching. Witnesses emphasized how biases can affect students’ intellectual and emotional growth, potentially discouraging critical thinking and limiting their ability to form well-rounded perspectives. Bias can also impact classroom dynamics, creating divisions among students and fostering environments where dissenting opinions are marginalized. For educators, the pressure to align with institutional ideologies may hinder their ability to teach freely and objectively, further perpetuating the cycle of bias. Addressing these challenges requires a commitment to transparency, openness to ideas, freedom of speech and accountability within educational institutions. Schools must actively promote ideological neutrality, ensuring that diverse perspectives are represented in curriculum materials and classroom discussions. Professional development for educators can play a critical role in helping them recognize and mitigate their own biases, fostering a more balanced and supportive learning environment. Additionally, schools should engage parents and community members in meaningful dialogue about educational content and policies, reinforcing trust and collaboration. Unfortunately much of the professional development training currently being offered is highly charged with ideologies which do not necessarily align with the local community social norms. The testimonies presented at the Vancouver NCI hearings highlight the importance of addressing teacher and administrative bias to create equitable and open non-biased ideologically neutral educational environments. By prioritizing neutrality and fostering open dialogue, schools can empower students to think critically, engage respectfully with differing viewpoints, and develop the skills necessary to navigate a complex and diverse world. Discussion of Witness Testimonies Several key witnesses addressed the issue of teacher and administrative bias, describing instances where personal or institutional biases appeared to affect the educational experience of students. Barry Neufeld Overview of Testimony Barry Neufeld is a former school board trustee who has been a vocal critic of SOGI 123 and its implementation in British Columbia schools. He has consistently advocated for balanced educational practices that respect different perspectives. Key Points of Testimony Bias in Curriculum Implementation : Neufeld criticized how programs like SOGI 123 were introduced without balanced debate or input from a broad range of stakeholders. He argued that the program promotes a specific ideology, sidelining alternative perspectives. Suppression of Dissent : Neufeld highlighted how educators or administrators who questioned these programs were often marginalized, creating an environment where open dialogue was discouraged. Paul Jaffe Overview of Testimony Paul Jaffe is an advocate who represented Barry Neufeld in his legal battles, regarding opposition to SOGI 123. Jaffe’s testimony during the NCI Vancouver Hearings emphasized the challenges and consequences faced by individuals, including parents, who voice concerns about perceived bias within educational systems. Key Points of Testimony Consequences of Speaking Out : Jaffe highlighted the backlash Neufeld faced for expressing his concerns about the ideological content of SOGI 123, including public criticism, professional ostracization, and legal challenges. This served as a broader warning about the risks parents and community members might face when questioning institutional policies. Chilling Effect on Free Expression : Jaffe argued that the treatment of Neufeld and others creates a chilling effect, deterring parents and educators from voicing legitimate concerns about teacher or administrative bias. He emphasized that this stifles open dialogue and prevents critical examination of controversial programs. Systemic Resistance to Dissent : According to Jaffe, educational institutions often dismiss or marginalize opposing viewpoints, further alienating parents who feel their voices are not respected. He noted that this resistance erodes trust between families and schools and discourages different perspectives from being represented in educational settings. Jaffe’s testimony underscores the systemic barriers parents may face when challenging perceived bias in schools and highlights the need for protecting free expression and fostering open dialogue. Hila Russ-Woodland Overview of Testimony Hila Russ-Woodland, an educator and advocate, testified about administrative priorities that she believes disregard parental and student concerns in favour of institutional policies. Key Points of Testimony Institutional Bias : Russ-Woodland described instances where controversial classroom materials and activities were prioritized without adequately considering the concerns of parents or the developmental readiness of students. Favouritism Toward Specific Agendas : She expressed concerns that some schools prioritize certain ideological viewpoints, fostering an imbalance in the educational experience. Chris Elston (Billboard Chris) Overview of Testimony Chris Elston, known as "Billboard Chris," is an advocate who focuses on the impact of gender ideology on children and the role of educators in promoting these ideas. Key Points Normalization of Ideologies : Elston criticized how educators promote specific ideologies, particularly around gender identity, without presenting diverse perspectives. He argued that this creates an unbalanced learning environment for students. Influence on Student Perception : He noted how teacher bias can shape students’ understanding of complex social issues, often discouraging critical thinking and exploration of alternative views. Emily Duggan Overview of Testimony Emily Duggan is a parental rights advocate who has actively opposed the perceived lack of balance in programs like SOGI 123. Her testimony focused on the need for transparency and inclusivity in curriculum development. Key Points of Testimony Ideological Bias in Curriculum : Duggan testified that programs like SOGI 123 reflect a singular ideological perspective, often excluding alternative viewpoints. She argued this approach undermines diversity and critical thinking in education. Lack of Transparency : Duggan emphasized that the lack of openness about such programs perpetuates administrative bias and alienates parents from their children’s education. Pierre Barnes Overview of Testimony Pierre Barnes, an advocate with personal experience in foster care, testified about the impact of administrative policies on parental trust and student welfare. Key Points of Testimony Policies Undermining Parental Authority : Barnes highlighted administrative policies that encourage teachers to withhold information about students from their parents, particularly on issues like gender identity. He argued this practice fosters mistrust and demonstrates administrative bias. Impact on Family-School Relationships : He stressed that such policies erode the foundational trust necessary for effective collaboration between families and schools. Amrit Birring Overview of Testimony Amrit Birring is a parent and community advocate who has spoken out against administrative complicity in promoting biased policies and practices in schools. Key Points of Testimony Administrative Complicity in Bias : Birring argued that school administrations often promote content and policies reflecting specific ideological stances while disregarding parental and community input. Call for Accountability : He called for greater accountability in administrative decision-making to ensure that policies and practices align with community values and diverse perspectives. These profiles provide a detailed foundation for discussing teacher and administrative bias in education. Discussion and Analysis of Issues Raised by the Witnesses Influence of Personal Beliefs on Instruction Witnesses such as Barry Neufeld and Emily Duggan raised concerns about educators allowing personal beliefs to influence instructional practices. For example, Neufeld testified that programs like SOGI 123 encouraged teachers to adopt specific ideological stances, particularly regarding gender identity and social justice. Duggan emphasized that such advocacy risks prioritizing personal or institutional ideologies over balanced education. While educators play a vital role in promoting diversity and inclusion, it is crucial that they maintain neutrality to foster critical thinking. Allowing personal beliefs to dominate classroom discussions can pressure students to conform to specific viewpoints, discouraging open inquiry and exploration of alternative perspectives. Schools should aim to create environments where students can critically assess multiple ideas and form their own informed opinions without feeling coerced. Lack of Alternate Perspectives in Curriculum Content Duggan and Paul Jaffe highlighted that some curriculum frameworks, such as those addressing gender identity, present one-sided narratives, often excluding alternative viewpoints. Duggan argued that students are rarely exposed to differing perspectives, limiting their ability to critically evaluate complex issues. Jaffe added that administrative support for certain ideologies further discourages dissent or discussion of alternative viewpoints, stifling intellectual diversity. Education thrives on the exchange of ideas, enabling students to engage with varying perspectives and develop critical thinking skills. When curricula favour a singular narrative, it creates an echo chamber that undermines students' ability to engage respectfully and thoughtfully with broader societal debates. Balanced content is essential for fostering open-mindedness and academic integrity. Administrative Support for Certain Ideologies Paul Jaffe and Pierre Barnes testified that school administrations often align with specific ideological stances, creating environments where questioning these positions is discouraged. Jaffe highlighted the backlash Barry Neufeld faced when he publicly critiqued SOGI 123, noting that administrative bias against dissenting views perpetuates a culture of suppression. Barnes added that policies restricting parental access to information, such as those involving a student’s gender identity, demonstrate administrative alignment with specific ideologies over family engagement. Administrative support for particular ideologies can alienate parents, students, and educators who hold differing views, creating a climate of distrust. School administrations must uphold policies that support respectful discourse and protect different perspectives without endorsing specific viewpoints. Impact on Student Expression and Classroom Dynamics Witnesses including Duggan, Dr. Ponesse and Hila Russ-Woodland highlighted how teacher and administrative bias impacts classroom dynamics, leading students to feel reluctant to express differing opinions. Duggan recounted instances where students felt pressured to align with dominant classroom ideologies to avoid ostracization. Similarly, Russ-Woodland described how biased instructional practices created environments where alternative perspectives were disregarded. Classrooms should be safe spaces for exploration and intellectual growth. When bias influences classroom dynamics, students may feel marginalized or silenced, which undermines their confidence and ability to engage critically. Encouraging respectful dialogue and presenting multiple perspectives are vital to fostering a balanced learning environment. Implications for Parental Trust and Community Relations The perception of bias in schools also affects trust between parents and educational institutions. Witnesses such as Neufeld and Birring emphasized that when teachers and administrators take explicit stances on sensitive issues, it alienates parents who feel their values are disregarded. This lack of alignment between home and school creates tension and erodes trust, particularly when parents are excluded from conversations about curriculum content or policies. Building trust requires schools to respect multiple family values and ensure transparency in policy decisions. By involving parents in curriculum development and maintaining open communication, schools can foster stronger community relationships and promote a shared commitment to student success. Conclusion The witness testimonies highlight significant concerns about teacher and administrative bias in Canadian schools. These include the influence of personal beliefs on instruction, lack of diverse perspectives in curriculum content, and administrative alignment with specific ideologies. Witnesses emphasized how these factors can stifle intellectual growth, suppress dissenting voices, and erode trust between families and schools. By addressing these issues, educational institutions can create more balanced environments that support critical thinking, respect different perspectives, and uphold the rights of students and families. Recommendations Promote Ideological Neutrality in Classroom Instruction: Provide professional development for educators on maintaining neutrality when presenting sensitive or controversial topics. Train teachers to facilitate balanced discussions that respect different viewpoints and encourage critical inquiry. 2. Encourage Different Perspectives in Curriculum Content: Ensure that curriculum materials present a variety of perspectives on complex social issues. Conduct regular reviews of educational content to identify and address potential biases, promoting intellectual freedom. 3. Establish Policies Against Administrative Endorsement of Ideologies: Develop clear guidelines to prevent school administrations from endorsing specific ideologies. Implement safeguards to ensure policies support open discourse and protect the rights of students, parents, and teachers to express different opinions. 4. Create Guidelines for Teacher Conduct and Bias Awareness: Develop guidelines to help teachers recognize and mitigate their own biases in instructional practices. Include regular training on respectful communication and handling all perspectives effectively. 5. Implement Classroom Climate Assessments: Conduct periodic surveys to gather feedback from students and parents on classroom dynamics. Use this data to identify areas where teacher or administrative bias may be affecting the learning environment. 6. Strengthen Parental Engagement and Communication: Enhance communication with parents regarding curricular content and policies, ensuring they are informed and involved. Create avenues for parents to share concerns and participate in discussions about sensitive topics. 7. Protect Free Expression for Students and Educators: Uphold policies that protect the right of students and educators to express opinions without fear of reprisal. Ensure that dissenting viewpoints are respected and given equal consideration in classroom and administrative settings. 8. Establish an Oversight Committee for Bias and Neutrality: Form an oversight committee to review curriculum, classroom practices, and administrative policies for signs of bias. Include educators, parents, and students in the committee to ensure a balanced approach. By implementing these recommendations, schools can foster an educational environment that values freedom of thought, critical thinking, and mutual respect, while strengthening trust between families and educational institutions. Report Content Reader Page 📄 Note to Readers The content presented on this page has been adapted for online viewing and navigation. Due to formatting limitations within the web display system, certain elements—such as layout, spacing, and visual structure—may differ slightly from the original report. For the complete and fully formatted version, we encourage you to download the official PDF available on the Report Information page. The PDF reflects the report exactly as it was originally written and published.

  • NCI-R-02-Item-7-1-8 | National Citizens Ar

    7.1.8 Emergency Planning & Plan Execution 7.1.8. Emeergency Planning & Plan Execution Introduction An essential role of any government is to plan for and act appropriately during times of national or regional emergencies. This function of government has been recognized in Canada for decades, and in the 1950s the federal government established a training college to provide emergency training courses and to foster training and cooperation in emergency situations between federal, provincial, and territorial governments. Emergency response training is still provided by the federal government through the Canadian Emergency Management College. On their website, Public Safety Canada states the following: Natural disasters, pandemics, cyber incidents and terrorism can all cause emergencies in Canada. Emergencies can quickly escalate in scope and severity, cross jurisdictional lines, and take on international dimensions. Emergency management planning can save lives, preserve the environment and protect property by raising the understanding of risks and contributing to a safer, prosperous, sustainable, disaster resistant, and resilient society in Canada. Emergency management is a core responsibility of the Government of Canada and a collective responsibility of all federal government institutions. This is why Public Safety Canada is taking steps to promote a coordinated approach and more uniform structure to the management of emergencies by providing guidance to federal government institutions on how to develop emergency management plans. A coordinated approach to emergency management planning will strengthen the Government of Canada‘s capacity to prevent, protect against, respond to, and recover from major disasters and other emergencies. The “Emergency Management Planning Guide” supports federal institutions in meeting their responsibilities under the Emergency Management Act to prepare and maintain mandate-specific emergency management plans. The Guide provides the framework for federal government institutions to undertake mandate-specific all-hazards risk assessments and planning activities within all four integrated functions of emergency management: mitigation/prevention , preparedness , response , and recovery . The Government of Canada has a federal policy for emergency management, as set out on the following website: https://www.publicsafety.gc.ca/cnt/rsrcs/pblctns/plc-mrgnc-mngmnt/index-en.aspx According to the federal policy for emergency management: The federal government is responsible for emergency management at the national level in its exclusive jurisdictions and on lands and properties under federal responsibility. Provincial and territorial governments exercise responsibility for emergency management within their respective jurisdictions except where legislation allows for direct federal intervention or for shared responsibility. If any emergency threatens to overwhelm the resources of a province or territory, federal institutions may respond to the request or if an emergency has a national implication. A provincial request for assistance during an emergency indicates that the province requires federal support to achieve an objective. While the province may indicate the specific resources and capabilities required, in most instances federal departments and agencies will need to define the appropriate response. Federal institutions can also make preparations in advance of anticipated need or request for assistance from a province or territory. In researching how the provincial governments have integrated their own emergency response programs, a number of provincial programs were reviewed. The government of Manitoba‘s website includes a copy of The Emergency Measures Act which sets out the responsibilities of the provincial and municipal governments in case of an emergency. Other provincial governments and territories in Canada have similar legislation to deal with emergencies. In Ontario, the legislation is called the Emergency Management and Civil Protection Act In Alberta, the legislation is called the Emergency Management Act . It is imperative, following the implementation of emergency plans during the COVID-19 pandemic, to evaluate the emergency measures undertaken to evaluate their effectiveness in mitigating the risks associated with the COVID-19 outbreak, and to determine whether or not the steps taken actually adhered to the legislation at all levels of government as set out by the various legislations. To undertake this task, the Commissioners have relied on the testimony of various witnesses who appeared at the hearings. Testimony Concerning Emergency Planning & Plan Execution During Pandemic Direct testimony was received from witnesses concerning the actions of the various levels of governments during the COVID-19 emergency or pandemic. Witnesses included the following: Lieutenant Colonel David Redman Canada Deviated from Strategic Pandemic Response Lt. Col. Redman testified that most provinces and territories in Canada approach emergencies in a similar way. The emergencies measures organizations in Canada are tasked with responding to all manner of emergencies in Canada, while mitigating the effects of the emergency on the totality of Canadians‘ society. Every province and territory in Canada had a pandemic plan prepared prior to the declaration of the COVID-19 pandemic in March of 2020. https://pandemicalternative.org/index.php/resources/11-resource-pandemic-plan The following was taken from the Pandemic Alternative Website, as presented by Lt. Col. Redman: Pandemic Plans from around Canada Pandemic plans listed on the Government of Canada website https://www.canada.ca/en/public-health/services/flu-influenza/pandemic-plans.html Alberta‘s Influenza Pandemic Plan (2014) https://open.alberta.ca/dataset/c89245b6-a7fc-4c24-be87-c2686341ffb5/resource/a652811e-42f2-4c0d-90af-54e0e759e05e/download/2014-albertas-pandemic-influenza-plan-apip-march-2014.pdf British Columbia‘s Influenza Pandemic Plan (2014) https://www.crd.bc.ca/docs/default-source/emergency-pdf/bc-pandemic-influenza-consequence-management-plan.pdf?sfvrsn=0 Manitoba‘s Influenza Pandemic Plan https://www.gov.mb.ca/asset_library/en/documents/influenza/Pandemic_Overview.pdf Newfoundland‘s Pandemic Plan (2007) https://www.gov.nl.ca/hcs/files/publichealth-pandemic-complete-pandemic-web.pdf New Brunswick‘s Influenza Pandemic Plan (2006) https://www2.gnb.ca/content/dam/gnb/Departments/ps-sp/pdf/emo/Pandemic_Planning-e.pdf Northwest Territories‘ Pandemic Guide (2020) https://www.hss.gov.nt.ca/professionals/sites/professionals/files/resources/hss_pandemic_guide_and_checklist.pdf Nova Scotia‘s Influenza Pandemic Plan (2013) https://novascotia.ca/dhw/cdpc/documents/Respiratory_Response_Plan_for_Public_Health.pdf Nunavut‘s Pandemic Path (2020) https://gov.nu.ca/sites/default/files/nunavuts_path_final_framework_-_eng_sm.pdf Ontario‘s Influenza Pandemic Plan (2013) http://www.health.gov.on.ca/en/pro/programs/emb/pan_flu/pan_flu_plan.aspx Prince Edward Island‘s Pandemic Plan https://www.princeedwardisland.ca/sites/default/files/publications/pandemic_influenza_contingency_plan.pdf Québec‘s Influenza Pandemic Plan (2006) https://publications.msss.gouv.qc.ca/msss/fichiers/2005/05-235-05a.pdf Saskatchewan‘s Influenza Pandemic Plan (2009) https://www.homelesshub.ca/sites/default/files/vmd0jm0k.pdf Yukon Territory‘s Influenza Pandemic Plan (2020) https://yukon.ca/sites/yukon.ca/files/cs/cs-yg-pandemic-coordination-plan.pdf None of the provincial or federal governments fully utilized the recommendations contained in those existing plans. The COVID-19 pandemic response was flawed from the very beginning in the following ways: The responses did not take into account the emergency pandemic plans that had already been created; The overall goal of the pandemic response was incorrect. The stated goal was to “protect the healthcare system.“ A more appropriate goal should have been to minimize the impact of the virus/disease on all of society. The government did not utilize the preexisting emergency response apparatus that existed at all levels of government. Each province and territory had professional people trained in planning for implementing and monitoring an integrated response to any and all emergency situations. All emergency responses in Canada are to be under the direct control and supervision of elected officials. During the COVID-19 pandemic, control and authority of all aspects of Canadian society were handed over to non-elected bureaucrats within the healthcare area. These individuals were not elected, and had no substantive actual training in coordinating a response to an emergency situation. Fear and terror were used to control the population. The government representatives did not express confidence in their plan, nor did they express an overall plan to the population. No new surge capacity was constructed within the medical system, and the government took steps to eliminate normal services in order to free up resources. This resulted in lack of medical services for the overall population, including cancellation of care, diagnosis, and treatment of disease and injuries. A major planning mistake was bringing people infected with COVID-19 into existing hospitals, thereby potentially infecting the entire facility and staff. If COVID-19 had indeed been the deadly pathogen that we were told, separate treatment centres should have been set up to isolate COVID patients from the existing system that was needed to provide general healthcare. The sharing of resources across jurisdictions is a normal function during emergencies, but this practice was discouraged and demonized during the COVID-19 pandemic. The media used any hint of this to make the case that the healthcare system was overwhelmed. The government appeared to be unaware of what was going on in the healthcare system and in society overall. The measures that had initially been implemented were not adjusted based on the actual situation being experienced on the ground. An example of this might be that although it was understood as early as March of 2020 that different population groups had different levels of risk and outcomes from COVID-19, resources were expended needlessly in groups that had little or no risk from dying of COVID-19. Pandemics are “public emergencies,“ not “public health emergencies.“ The Premier of every province should have established a task force made up of major public sector ministries to lead, coordinate, and support the efforts. In no instance should public health have been put in the lead of the emergency plan and its overall execution across the entire society. The coordinating agency EMO (emergency measures organization) should have been in charge of the entire response across all societal sectors, this would have guaranteed a balanced and considered response. Those who developed and implemented the government response did not fully understand the economic and social impacts of the mitigative measures and attempted to minimize these impacts. Continuity of all services and businesses should have been a priority, with assistance being provided to those areas which were actually prevented from accomplishing their tasks. No considerations were given to the protection of individual rights and freedoms. Government and public health messaging failed to address and manage fear, and instead stoked and inflamed it. A realistic cost–benefit analysis was never carried out for each of the measures undertaken so that all effects of the proposed measures could be analyzed. Non-pharmaceutical interventions had previously been studied and most were determined to be non-effective; however, they were implemented without consideration of previous experience or reasons given for why they would be appropriate for this particular pandemic. No written plans were ever issued by the government or the media to the public so that citizens could make informed decisions. Government and media collaborated to promote a certain narrative without consideration of the actual known facts and information. Both the government and media developed a narrative which demonized persons who had tested positive for COVID-19 and/or were demonstrating symptoms of COVID-19. A recovery plan was never developed or implemented to address the widespread damage that had been done to Canadian society. Seventy-three per cent of all reported COVID-19 deaths occurred in long-term-care facilities. This is a controlled and contained population which should have effectively been addressed in a focused way. Medical professionals, who were asked during their testimony, had no training or awareness of any pre-existing influenza pandemic plan. Conclusions The Canadian response to the COVID-19 pandemic failed in all major areas of emergency response management. Emergency response was put in the hands of unelected health officers, and elected officials abrogated their legislated responsibilities. Emergency response planning and implementation must be carried out from the bottom up, since the circumstances of any emergency vary based on actual conditions on the ground. Federal authorities implemented emergency plans across the country, as opposed to only providing support to local emergency plans. Despite the existence of detailed pandemic response plans, the government response to the COVID-19 pandemic ignored most of these pandemic response plans. Existing emergency measures personnel and procedures were not utilized during the pandemic. The government pandemic plan did not evaluate the overall collateral effects of the measures implemented. The pandemic measures imposed by government did not take into account the evolving situation. Recommendations Based on the totality of the witness testimony, the following recommendations are presented: A. Emergency measures organizations (EMOs) must be in charge of planning, implementation, and recovery from any and all “emergencies.“ B. Public health officials should never be put in charge of emergency response. They should be a critical component of the planning but should never be charged with running a response. C. Emergency Management Act powers must supersede the powers of the various public health officers. The public health officers must come under the authority of the emergency management agencies. D. Elected officials must remain in charge of all emergency measures. E. Follow existing emergency plans. F. Make sure all emergency plans are publicized and the contents well known by stakeholders in all affected areas. G. Require mandatory training of emergency response personnel. H. Follow all emergency measures legislation in each jurisdiction. I. Emergency planning must be driven from the bottom up. J. Federal government should not be leading emergency response. They should be limited to supporting the requirements of the local authorities. K. Media and government cannot be allowed to collude to present a pre-approved information campaign. L. The consultation process should involve the public, and the comprehensive plan to tackle the pandemic emergency should be regularly, consistently, and promptly communicated to the public. M. In any future emergencies , the government should focus on mitigating public fear and anxiety rather than resorting to fear and terror as a means to secure compliance. N. Require mandatory cost–benefit analysis of any and all emergency measures considered and/or imposed. O. Require transparency in decision-making. P. Support open public discourse , without censorship. Q. Require a mandatory recovery plan to fix the collateral damage done by the pandemic measures. R. Require a mitigation plan for all societal damage done by the pandemic measures. S. Establish regulations to ensure that the elected officials are never sidelined or abrogate their powers to unelected bureaucrats. T. Commission an independent study which is required to include members of the emergency measures organizations from across Canada. U. Rebuild emergency response organizations across Canada. Report Content Reader Page 📄 Note to Readers The content presented on this page has been adapted for online viewing and navigation. Due to formatting limitations within the web display system, certain elements—such as layout, spacing, and visual structure—may differ slightly from the original report. For the complete and fully formatted version, we encourage you to download the official PDF available on the Report Information page. The PDF reflects the report exactly as it was originally written and published.

National Citizens Archive
Witness Testimony | Commissioner Reports | Research Archive

© National Citizens Archive

Disclaimer: The National Citizens Archive is an independent archival and research initiative created to preserve, organize, and make accessible historical materials, testimony, transcripts, reports, and related public records arising from the National Citizens Inquiry process. The National Citizens Archive is not the official website of the federally incorporated National Citizens Inquiry organization, and no formal legal, corporate, or governance relationship should be inferred unless and until such a relationship is expressly agreed to in writing by the relevant parties.

Divider Lines_edited.png
bottom of page